Dämon Posted October 2 Posted October 2 Just now, opbranden said: Hide contents I guess she's pro-choice Imo, I feel like her entire character could have been removed, and Arthur's endgame would have stayed pretty much the same. Lee wasn't "needed", but was just "added," if that makes sense. But maybe it's just me, I really hated how Todd wrote his Harley Spoiler My guess is that the movie truly was supposed to have Gaga as a lead. And we were supposed to watch Lee get crazy while Arthur became his normal self + get more backstory on Lee. Not sure why they switched but my guess is that the movie would have been way too long and they changed directions to focus on Arthur to cater to male audience… those are my guesses but you can just FEEL Lee was supposed to have a parallel story 2
Matthew Posted October 2 Posted October 2 Can someone confirm whether any of Harlequin's songs are eligible for BOS? I thought none were but someone said FAD was (not Gaga, the song). 1 10
Edonis Posted October 2 Posted October 2 12 minutes ago, Dämon said: Also I'm sorry but Hide contents Lee announcing she's pregnant and then the movie never addressing it again? Why would they drop that and then just not anything with it they could have cut that line and the movie would have been the same so I'm utterly confused by it I- what is this film nnnn
EnigmaticAndroid Posted October 2 Posted October 2 Just now, sunbathinganimal said: thank god i'm getting drunk before I watch it The way I'm gonna have to watch this sh*t stone cold sober. 7
sunbathinganimal Posted October 2 Posted October 2 Just now, Matthew said: someone said FAD was (not Gaga, the song). 3
Almodusa Posted October 2 Posted October 2 Just now, Matthew said: Can someone confirm whether any of Harlequin's songs are eligible for BOS? I thought none were but someone said FAD was (not Gaga, the song). Spoiler FAD is because it's in the film (with singing). So Gaga is eligible since she said she wrote the waltz for the film. 1 1
Dämon Posted October 2 Posted October 2 1 minute ago, Matthew said: Can someone confirm whether any of Harlequin's songs are eligible for BOS? I thought none were but someone said FAD was (not Gaga, the song). Girl 1
DoctorIce Posted October 2 Posted October 2 I'm still floored by that Jimmy Kimmel performance. THAT is why she will never be a fad despite what notorious Katy stans (who tried and failed to covertly rebrand as Adele stans) try and tell us. 3 1
TrymeB Posted October 2 Posted October 2 Justin Clark from Slant (a top critic) gave it a 25/100 score Scott Mendelson (who I thought was a Liddo) has given it a 20/100 score. They say good things about Gaga though.
Dumbledore Posted October 2 Posted October 2 1 minute ago, DoctorIce said: I'm still floored by that Jimmy Kimmel performance. THAT is why she will never be a fad despite what notorious Katy stans (who tried and failed to covertly rebrand as Adele stans) try and tell us. No offense but does Adele have stans? What are they called? Adelers? Spoiler Gaga queen Katy flop
Mr. Stratus Posted October 2 Posted October 2 (edited) 2 minutes ago, DoctorIce said: I'm still floored by that Jimmy Kimmel performance. THAT is why she will never be a fad despite what notorious Katy stans (who tried and failed to covertly rebrand as Adele stans) try and tell us. that's not a Katy Stan honestly it's a Britney stan I saw it losing its sh*t over Xtina outstreaming Brit thread and so is that other 'liddo' in here only posting bad updates. They're weird over Gaga's movie career, good job she's far from RETIRED or FIRED from acting so we don't have to cosplay or change are AVIs 💋 Edited October 2 by Mr. Stratus
Dumbledore Posted October 2 Posted October 2 Just now, TrymeB said: Justin Clark from Slant (a top critic) gave it a 25/100 score Scott Mendelson (who I thought was a Liddo) has given it a 20/100 score. They say good things about Gaga though. Oh wow Good Bombing indeed oh wow
Almodusa Posted October 2 Posted October 2 1 minute ago, Dumbledore said: No offense but does Adele have stans? What are they called? Adelers? Reveal hidden contents Gaga queen Katy flop Adelephants is usually the term I see ot: fàd
Nando_05 Posted October 2 Posted October 2 9 minutes ago, Dumbledore said: Bitchhhh I was there. It was CRAZY
TheGerm Posted October 2 Posted October 2 Just now, Almodusa said: Adelephants is usually the term I see ot: fàd im so out of touch with her and her fan base but someone please tell me this is a joke
Dumbledore Posted October 2 Posted October 2 Just now, Almodusa said: Adelephants is usually the term I see ot: fàd I don't wanna get dragged but is this a joke like... Why elephants of ALL things? Spoiler Gaga mother Richy RAT 1
Hair Posted October 2 Posted October 2 2 minutes ago, Almodusa said: Adelephants is usually the term I see ot: fàd Just now, TheGerm said: im so out of touch with her and her fan base but someone please tell me this is a joke They're called Daydreamers 1
TheGerm Posted October 2 Posted October 2 Just now, Nando_05 said: I was there. It was CRAZY This is so ******* wild...... please share more about this day, i am gagged.
Dumbledore Posted October 2 Posted October 2 Just now, Hair said: They're called Daydreamers Oh thank god, anyways stream Happy Mistake 3
sunbathinganimal Posted October 2 Posted October 2 at least Gár is acclaimed so OGHs don't get the satisfaction of dragging her acting, even when she loses she wins 4 1
Azor Ahai Posted October 2 Posted October 2 22 minutes ago, Dämon said: Also I'm sorry but Reveal hidden contents Lee announcing she's pregnant and then the movie never addressing it again? Why would they drop that and then just not anything with it they could have cut that line and the movie would have been the same so I'm utterly confused by it Spoiler There's two hints about the resolution of this. When Arthur asks her, she sings that's entertainment which to me is a hint she made up the baby just to make him fall in love with her more. The other hint is that he had a visitor right before the end of the movie. As we never find who was trying to visit him, it could have been her to talk about the baby. 1
opbranden Posted October 2 Posted October 2 6 minutes ago, Dämon said: Hide contents My guess is that the movie truly was supposed to have Gaga as a lead. And we were supposed to watch Lee get crazy while Arthur became his normal self + get more backstory on Lee. Not sure why they switched but my guess is that the movie would have been way too long and they changed directions to focus on Arthur to cater to male audience… those are my guesses but you can just FEEL Lee was supposed to have a parallel story Spoiler I totally agree! People thought I was crazy for speculating, but after watching the movie, it's obvious that A LOT was cut. Early screenings had people saying Gaga was overshadowing Phoenix, which shows she was clearly meant for a bigger role. Even when Gaga talks about her character, it makes me wonder, "Where is this incredible Lee you're describing?" In the movie, she just feels like a shadow of what could have been a much more impactful character. Regardless, she delivered a great performance. It's just disappointing to see that she poured her heart into the project, only for Todd to reduce her role to a mere sidenote. 1
Recommended Posts