Jump to content

Least respected legend among GP: Madonna, Mariah or MJ?


Donquizote

Recommended Posts

Kiss It Better

it was Mariah until she switched her team and fixed her social media presence, now it's Madonna i think 

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Replies 121
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • stevyy

    6

  • Don't Stop Me Now

    6

  • Joey....

    5

  • GlamSlam

    5

On what basis? MJ may have the pedo accusations and his face/surgeries but despite that he is still revered on a talent's point of view on a level that is surreal and unreachable to both women. It's between Madonna and Mariah. Both are respected, I don't think the GP really care that much about Madonna's twitter antics or weird sense of humour as much as Atrl thinks. 

Link to post
Share on other sites
GreatestLoveofAll

Madonna probably. For as much hate as MJ got and still gets from people who dont like his music/believe the child abuse allegations, his talent and impact will always make him beloved for generations. The other two dont have that. 

Link to post
Share on other sites
tootight49

Mariah has had more impact and it appears enjoys a better legendary status to the GP than Madonna whose catalogue can’t even get a 1/5th of Mariah’s non-Christmas catalogue in any given year.

 

Of course AIWFC and the Christmas album single-handedly obliterate Madonna’s entire catalogue to the new streaming generation 💃

Edited by tootight49
Link to post
Share on other sites
aesthetic bih

Despite the allegations, MJ still has a lot of supporters and defenders claiming he's innocent. Mariah is more balanced so yeah. Madonna, not so much.

 So overall:

 

Most respected:

Mariah > MJ > Madonna

Edited by aesthetic bih
Link to post
Share on other sites
suburbannature
2 minutes ago, Filpo said:

Not you all acting like "Mariah Carey" is a thing outside the USA. Her.

 

She'd still be 6th-7th best selling female of all time without any US sales (the largest music market in the world). Suffer.

GEiT2kv.gif

Link to post
Share on other sites

madonna for now but but when she dies it will be MJ

 

being dead + embarrassing is far more respectable than being dead + a pedophile

Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, Filpo said:

Not you all acting like "Mariah Carey" is a thing outside the USA. Her.

Madonna fans still using this fictional narrative against Moo. 

GEiT2kv.gif

 

Edited by EJQL8
Illiteracy
Link to post
Share on other sites
  • #FreeBritney Activist
On 1/11/2021 at 2:01 PM, Earth Ripper said:

Mariah. She's liked (esp. during the holiday season) but who respects her nowadays, honestly. At least Madonna gets frequently mentioned for her impact and trailblazing. Mariah only ever had her voice and nowadays her NYE disaster video comes to mind faster than anything else, so...

Mariah is respected for her once great voice and talent as a songwriter. Madonna is older than Mariah too and she uses her sexuality way more that’s why people mock her. Michael’s missteps seemed to be erased by his death.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Glamthony

This Madonna slander has to stop. Minimize her unreachable legacy in music is just pure misogyny. 

 

MJ, Steve Tyler, Mick Jagger, etc made a joke of themselves but no one bats an eye.

 

Its a shame gays among all people are trying so hard to erase Madonna's epic and legendary status with misoginistic bull****.

Link to post
Share on other sites
32 minutes ago, EJQL8 said:

Madonna fans still using this fictional narrative against Moo. 

GEiT2kv.gif

 

It makes them cope better. Without their respective US sales... Madonna (#1), Céline (#2) and Mariah (#3) would still rank as they rank with the their US sales.

Link to post
Share on other sites
discotitzz
18 hours ago, tootight49 said:

Mariah has had more impact and it appears enjoys a better legendary status to the GP than Madonna whose catalogue can’t even get a 1/5th of Mariah’s non-Christmas catalogue in any given year.

 

Of course AIWFC and the Christmas album single-handedly obliterate Madonna’s entire catalogue to the new streaming generation 💃

Diminishing the woman who paved the way for Mariah :deadbanana4: I stan both but what is this? Liddo hiding behind Mariah? 

Edited by discotitzz
Link to post
Share on other sites
teresaguidice

michael jackson was mostly an object of morbid fascination the last decade or so he was alive. he has remembered music and a large and vocal fanbase that lets their nostalgia for his music shield them from the truth, but you can't really compare a pedophile to madonna humiliating herself every day on instagram daily. he is least respected, rightfully. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Madonna

Tbh it's mostly due to sexism & ageism, the GP doesn't respect her as much because she doesn't "act her age" :devil: BS if you ask me.

 

Meanwhile Mariah's music was always more timeless/ageless (songs like AIWFCIY & Hero, she could be singing in her 80's and it would still be seen as age appropriate) and so she aged more gracefully to the GP

Plus Michael's untimely death gave him a halo affect.

 

I'm sure if Michael was alive today he probably would have been cancelled.

Link to post
Share on other sites
×
×
  • Create New...