[tcweh]

The REAL signature song's by both these amazing artists's (BAD ROMANCE AND WE FOUND LOVE CAN HAVE SEVERAL SEATS)

Australia (ARIA) 1
Austria (Ö3 Austria Top 75) 1
Belgium (Ultratop 50 Flanders) 1
Belgium (Ultratop 40 Wallonia) 3
Canada (Canadian Hot 100) 1
Czech Republic (IFPI) 2
Denmark (Tracklisten) 1
Netherlands (Mega Single Top 100)[ 2
European Hot 100 Singles1
Finland (Suomen virallinen lista) 2
France (SNEP) 6
Germany (Media Control AG) 1
Hungary (Rádiós Top 40) 1
Hungary (Single Top 10) 5
Ireland (IRMA) 1
Italy (FIMI) 3
New Zealand (RIANZ)1
Norway (VG-lista)1
South Africa (Mediaguide) 1
Sweden (Sverigetopplistan) 2
Switzerland (Schweizer Hitparade) 1
UK Singles (Official Charts Company) 1
US Billboard Hot 100 1
US Hot Dance Club Songs (Billboard) 1
US Hot R&B/Hip-Hop Songs (Billboard) 4
US Pop Songs (Billboard) 2

Australian Singles Chart[41] 1
Austrian Singles Chart[44] 1
Belgian Singles Chart (Flanders)[44] 1
Belgian Singles Chart (Wallonia)[44] 1
Canadian Hot 100[38] 1
Czech Airplay Chart[99] 2
Danish Singles Chart[44] 1
Dutch Top 40[44] 1
European Hot 100 Singles[55] 1
Finnish Singles Chart[44] 1
French Singles Chart[44] 1
German Singles Chart[52] 1
Hungarian Singles Chart[100] 6
Irish Singles Chart[53] 1
Israeli Airplay Chart[101] 2
Italian Singles Chart[44] 2
Japan Hot 100[102] 2
Mexico Top Inglés (Monitor Latino)[103] 1
New Zealand Singles Chart[44] 1
Norwegian Singles Chart[44] 1
Slovak Airplay Chart[104] 1
Spanish Singles Chart[44] 2
Swedish Singles Chart[44] 1
Swiss Singles Chart[44] 1
UK Singles Chart[47] 1
US Billboard Hot 100[28] 1
US Hot Dance Club Songs[105] 1
US Hot R&B/Hip-Hop Songs[105] 75
US Pop 100[105]

Which was the bigger success,Had bigger impact, And more memorable/aged better?

[Kang.]

Umbrella

[Jabril]

Poker Face

[Gagamon]

the iconic poker face

[coolcristobal]

nawT you shading BR and WFL tho

And I'd prefer Poker Face

[Monster Boy]

Poker Face.

[jomarr]

The one who started the repeating syllables trend

[rihannabiggestfan]

Umbrella by far.

[Cosmos]

Bad Romance > Poker Face.

That said, Poker Face > Umbrella. Poker Face was a massive trend-setting hit, and helped to really catapult electropop onto the radio. Umbrella is merely a solid pop/R&B song that came at the end of urban music's mainstream popularity. Plus, PF is a better song.

[TeamRHI]

Both are very memorable and were very successful. I voted for Umbrella though since I think Rihanna will be remembered longer than Gaga, which is unfortunate as both are great.

[Beautiful Sinner]

Umbrella.

[tcweh]

Originally posted by Cosmos

Bad Romance > Poker Face.

No. Poker face went #1 in more countries, Sold more, Had more impact, and is more remembered by the general public outside of ATRL, Bad romance is just a fan favorite, And it's no shade because it's my favorite Gaga song too, But I'm just giving the hard reality Boo

[jayyyxtee]

Originally posted by TeamRHI

Both are very memorable and were very successful. I voted for Umbrella though since I think Rihanna will be remembered longer than Gaga, which is unfortunate as both are great.

Poker Face is the obvious choice here

[Haus]

Poker Face was ahead of its time and was a massive help in the electropop movement, and its lyrics are better.

I still love both though

[Cannabis]

The ICONIC one.



Bigger impact and legacy

[MikeFenty]

Rihanna Umbrella

[Monroe]

Both are overrated. Umbrella felt like it was bigger though, you couldn't really escape that song. Poker Face was sandwiched in between bigger hits like Boom Boom Pow and I Got A Feeling from the Black Eyed Pea's and you never got the sense that it was really that huge because it was constantly being over shadowed by the others on the radio.

[BPD]

Which one is more successful? Honest question

[jomarr]

Originally posted by Haus

Poker Face was ahead of its time and was a massive help in the electropop movement, and its lyrics are better.

I still love both though

[NewRihannaStan]

The one that people will always use when it rains