[YoYo]

Originally posted by Meredy

Can she share that to the contesants? What does she know about harmonizing or vocal techniques when it's obvious that she needs a mentor herself, unlike Mariah.

So far Spears has tended to prefer “exciting” contestants who are visually appealing and charismatic performers rather than those who simply possess a fine voice.

- Entertainment Weekly

Which is MUCH more important than offering voice techniques than any vocal coach can offer (Mariah is a master of vocals so she will have more to give than an average coach but you know what I mean). We both know that it takes much more than that to make it in today's market. How many Idol winners with good voices have flopped like an anvil despite having good voices? Exactly

[KESTER]

Well I think Mariah will be the best judge (IMO) because she has a very sharp sense of humour. I think Britney will pull in the best ratings because people want to see her

[KESTER]

Originally posted by Meredy

It's a singing competition though. Mariah Carey knows how to use her voice and can teach the contestants technique. And Mariah Carey doesn't know how to be a huge star like Britney? And Mariah started at age 19. She writes and produces her own songs. She definitely knows more about singing.

The X Factor isn't just about singing though, it's the whole package. Dancing, singing and performing.

[supertiffany]

Originally posted by YoYo

- Entertainment Weekly

Which is MUCH more important than offering voice techniques than any vocal coach can offer (Mariah is a master of vocals so she will have more to give than an average coach but you know what I mean). We both know that it takes much more than that to make it in today's market. How many Idol winners with good voices have flopped like an anvil despite having good voices? Exactly

exactly. Mariah is not only has the VOICE, the X-FACTOR but she got both bu the COMPLETE PACKAGE

[Duca]

Originally posted by supertiffany

LOL. You underestimate Mariah's starpower. She will pull ratings to be honest I think far better than Xtina or same/almost same level with Britney. This isnt 2007 where Britney is the most controversial where in she's been always a hot item.

Britney slowly losing that over the years but not gone obviously however not as the same as what she had during those times.

Mariah has also more personality seeing how bitchy/controversial she speaks. Britney based on the off-cam reports about her judging on X-Factor is being overshadowed by sharp-tongued and personality loaded Demi Lovato.

Brit has been very isolated and boxed based on X-Factor offcam reports hope she'll be confident especially in the live rounds and we'll speak more than a few words .

Have you even read some of her comments?

"I want to know who let you on stage."

“To make a great performance, you have to step it up. There’s a big wall between us, and you need to learn to break it down.”

“I can’t look. I literally can’t look.”

"You can't destroy that song, sweetie."

”I’m sorry, honey, but you have to be great to be on this show.”

"I feel like your song was just in the wrong key. Your voice is really sweet, but I feel like you need a little more training."

Everyone was shocked at how brutally honest she was and how she wasn’t scared to say it straight.

Britney gave record-breaking ratings to every show she appeared on. She's currently the world's sixth most powerful celebrity, highest-paid female musician (her networh is also bigger than Mariah's,) and she's one of the most talked about celebrities on TV, radio, web, and in press. Christina never made the top 100 on either of the Forbes' charts (TV, radio, press, social, or web,) while Mariah made the top 100 only once, a decade ago, and has been absent since.

[Meredy]

Originally posted by YoYo

- Entertainment Weekly

Which is MUCH more important than offering voice techniques than any vocal coach can offer (Mariah is a master of vocals so she will have more to give than an average coach but you know what I mean). We both know that it takes much more than that to make it in today's market. How many Idol winners with good voices have flopped like an anvil despite having good voices? Exactly

Originally posted by SAFEYEAA

The X Factor isn't just about singing though, it's the whole package. Dancing, singing and performing.

Did you just shade Britney?
Like what tiffany said. Mariah got the voice and the X-Factor.

[Duca]

Originally posted by SAFEYEAA

The X Factor isn't just about singing though, it's the whole package. Dancing, singing and performing.

Exactly. Mariah never had the other two.

Originally posted by supertiffany

exactly. Mariah is not only has the VOICE, the X-FACTOR but she got both bu the COMPLETE PACKAGE

Originally posted by supertiffany

exactly. Mariah is not only has the VOICE, the X-FACTOR but she got both bu the COMPLETE PACKAGE

Mariah doesn't have the X Factor, while Britney defines it. Simple as that.

[YoYo]

Originally posted by Meredy

Did you just shade Britney?
Like what tiffany said. Mariah got the voice and the X-Factor.

I think both will offer their own unique advice to the contestants. Don't you agree?

[Meredy]

Originally posted by Duca

Have you even read some of her comments?

"I want to know who let you on stage."

“To make a great performance, you have to step it up. There’s a big wall between us, and you need to learn to break it down.”

“I can’t look. I literally can’t look.”

"You can't destroy that song, sweetie."

”I’m sorry, honey, but you have to be great to be on this show.”

"I feel like your song was just in the wrong key. Your voice is really sweet, but I feel like you need a little more training."

Everyone was shocked at how brutally honest she was and how she wasn’t scared to say it straight.

Britney gave record-breaking ratings to every show she appeared on. She's currently the world's sixth most powerful celebrity, highest-paid female musician (her networh is also bigger than Mariah's,) and she's one of the most talked about celebrities on TV, radio, web, and in press. Christina never made the top 100 on either of the Forbes' charts (TV, radio, press, social, or web,) while Mariah made the top 100 only once, a decade ago, and has been absent since.

Giving conclusion based on a sneak peek.

Forbes isn't everything. Some low profile people are there because they made $. And Xtina didn't report her finance. If she did she's sure shot to be included around early 2000s.

[Meredy]

Originally posted by YoYo

I think both will offer their own unique advice to the contestants. Don't you agree?

Agreed. I'm actually a Britney stan but I just stan harder for Mariah.

Originally posted by Duca

Exactly. Mariah never had the other two.





Mariah doesn't have the X Factor, while Britney defines it. Simple as that.

Nicole can sing, dance, and perform but look what happened. Britney has the X-Factor (but she's losing it) and Mariah still has it. Do you think Mariah would go this far if she doesn't? Please.

And it doesn't mean that if you can't dance, you don't have it. Whitney anyone?

[KESTER]

Originally posted by Meredy

Did you just shade Britney?
Like what tiffany said. Mariah got the voice and the X-Factor.

Noo!! Not at all! But what I mean is, Britney isn't known just for her singing, she's known for her performance art aswell. Where-as Mariah is known for her voice more than anything. I love Brit + Mariah

[Duca]

Originally posted by Meredy

Giving conclusion based on a sneak peek.

Forbes isn't everything. Some low profile people are there because they made $. And Xtina doesn't report her finance. Because if she did she's sure shot to be included around early 2000s.

Every artist's management reports their numbers. Christina's career networth was $60 million in 2007. She never made lots of money (she's not a touring act, much like Mariah) despite numerous endorsement deals and she was never relevant enough in the media to make the Celebrity 100. Mariah's networth according to numbers reported to Forbes is $225 million. Britney made $167 million in the past 4 years alone.

[SeanXtina]

Wait..

Weren't you guys laughing at Christina when she became a Coach/Judge almost 2 years ago..

Now Kelly Clarkson, Britney, Mariah, Etc are following in her same direction... How cute!

[Meredy]

Originally posted by Duca

Every artist's management reports their numbers. Christina's career networth was $60 million in 2007. She never made lots of money (she's not a touring act, much like Mariah) despite numerous endorsement deals and she was never relevant enough in the media to make the Celebrity 100. Mariah's networth according to numbers reported to Forbes is $225 million. Britney made $167 million in the past 4 years alone.

I edited doesn't though to didn't. Accdg. to some Xtina stans she didn't report her finances during the early 2000s but I don't know and IDGAF because it's out of topic.

[SeanXtina]

Originally posted by Duca

Every artist's management reports their numbers. Christina's career networth was $60 million in 2007. She never made lots of money (she's not a touring act, much like Mariah) despite numerous endorsement deals and she was never relevant enough in the media to make the Celebrity 100. Mariah's networth according to numbers reported to Forbes is $225 million. Britney made $167 million in the past 4 years alone.

Yeah because Christina did just 10 shows on her world tours like Mariah... Please go have a seat. You make no sense and you're talking out your ass as always.

[KESTER]

Originally posted by SeanXtina

Wait..

Weren't you guys laughing at Christina when she became a Coach/Judge almost 2 years ago..

Now Kelly Clarkson, Britney, Mariah, Etc are following in her same direction... How cute!

What's Kelly Clarkson a judge on?

[SeanXtina]

Originally posted by SAFEYEAA

What's Kelly Clarkson a judge on?

gurl.....

[KESTER]

Originally posted by SeanXtina

gurl.....

I wasn't being mean.. I genuinely don't know.

[Duca]

Originally posted by Meredy

Nicole can sing, dance, and perform but look what happened. Do you think Mariah would go this far if she doesn't? Please.

And it doesn't mean that if you can't dance, you don't have it. Whitney anyone?

Like Mariah, what’s Whitney known for except for her voice? The X Factor is much more than just singing, dancing, and performing. There are plenty of talented girls who can sing, dance, and perform well. Britney has that something that makes her stand out from everyone else. Christina, Jessica, Mandy, etc. all debuted at the same time. Why didn't they achieve half (or quarter) the success Britney had? After 15 years, Britney still leaves everyone wanting more, and everyone keeps wanting more from her. It's easy to fade into the background in Hollywood (there are plenty of celebrities that fizzle out after a few years,) but Britney has stayed in the spotlight for 15 years, following in the footsteps of other artists like Madonna. She even managed to recover from her infamous head-shaving incident in 2007 and to get back on top. She's managed to achieve great professional success as I have already mentioned, and she's in a good place personally, in a stable relationship, engaged, and spotted on many occasions playing with her cute two little boys.

[skyler]

mariah carey