[tcweh]

Which is the overall bigger star and has more success in the US?

[caleb.]

Kellegend

[Underdogs]

How many albums has Kelly sold in teh US?

[P!nkInside]

even though US is Kelly's biggest market...P!nk is still bigger than her.

[Guernica]

P!nk. Her last three albums sold a million+ in the US and Kelly's have not (including Stronger in it)

[P!nkInside]

P!nk's sales:
CTMH: 2.5M+
M!ss: 5.5M+
TT: 1M
IND: 1.5M+
FH: 2M
GH...SF!: 1M

13.5M+

[TheVoiceXtina]

Kelly

[EOMM92]

Are you serious ?

PINK!

[Michael]

P!nk.

[CoolestPerson12]

P!nk, she's more consistent with her sales and single success.

[Michael]

Originally posted by P!nkInside

P!nk's sales:
CTMH: 2.5M+
M!ss: 5.5M+
TT: 1M
IND: 1.5M+
FH: 2M
GH...SF!: 1M

13.5M+

Try This has shipped 1 million, but sold about 200k less than that. Still, I think P!nk has sold about 2 million more albums in the US than Kelly.

[Believe in Justin]

I have a feeling it's P!nk

[Luckystar]

Pink

[rihannabiggestfan]

Are you kidding me? P!nk

[TheFallenOne]

Pikn >>>> Kylle Kralscon

[EdgeOfAddiction]

Child honey boo boo, please. Kelly Clarkson is bigger in the US. The fact that Kelly is almost on par with P!nk's sales with one less album speaks volumes. Also, P!nk has been on hiatus for a while with her child while Kelly has been in positive limelight with her singing show, weight loss and smash singles. We'll see how P!nk fares with her next album. Till then, Kelly is the bigger star.

[Smartypants]

I absolutely love Kelly, but I think that P!nk is slightly bigger in the US than Kelly.

[P!nkInside]

Originally posted by EdgeOfAddiction

Child honey boo boo, please. Kelly Clarkson is bigger in the US. The fact that Kelly is almost on par with P!nk's sales with one less album speaks volumes. Also, P!nk has been on hiatus for a while with her child while Kelly has been in positive limelight with her singing show, weight loss and smash singles. We'll see how P!nk fares with her next album. Till then, Kelly is the bigger star.

Is that why P!nk's greatest hits outsold Stronger? And have AIEW and My December sold a Million in the US yet?

[Qwerty]

P!nk, but it's close.

[Addicted]

P!nk and Kelly are very similar, but P!nk has been around longer therefore she is more successful.

However in terms of recognition in the public eye i'd say they are level, maybe even Kelly has edged ahead with her most recent era and #1.

By the way Stronger will hit platinum, it's almost there and has outsold other pop girls latest efforts and is on it's way to passing some other pop girls latest efforts.