ATRL - Discussion: 'Raise Your Glass: The P!nk Rate' (#1 REVEALED)

madonnas · , 5:49 PM

Ooh awesome. I didn't see this before. I've heard all her albums except Can't Take Me Home in full, but I'll definitely need to re-listen to some. I am not going to be kind to some of I'm Not Dead and Funhouse though. It's just the way it is.

Aaron · , 5:57 PM

Excited to do this.

Underdogs · , 6:00 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by madonnas

Ooh awesome. I didn't see this before. I've heard all her albums except Can't Take Me Home in full, but I'll definitely need to re-listen to some. I am not going to be kind to some of I'm Not Dead and Funhouse though. It's just the way it is.

Sis you're always too hard on P!nk

madonnas · , 6:02 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Underdogs

Sis you're always too hard on P!nk

I'm really picky and have very high standards. I wouldn't take it personally. I actually like P!nk. I might be a bit too mean to I'm Not Dead cause I know a lot of people think it's her best (

).

Great Username · , 6:07 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by madonnas

I've heard all her albums except Can't Take Me Home in full

But that's her only good one. In fact, it's fantastic.

madonnas · , 6:11 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Great Username

But that's her only good one. In fact, it's fantastic.

Well, I like Most Girls, so we'll see what I think about the others.

I think Try This is her best, and it's not perfect but it's a solid 8/10.

madonnas · , 6:53 PM

After skimming through I'm Not Dead again, I realize I actually enjoy most of it.

I always think I like her songs less than I actually do for some reason.

Pelvic Thrust · , 7:29 PM

Will do this this weekend! :woohoo2:

sticks · , 8:16 PM

Oh gosh, I want to participate, but I'll have to properly listen to the first three albums and then brush up on I'm Not Dead, but everything else should be fine.

Please remind me to vote!

madonnas · , 9:06 PM

Sent!

Averages

My 10/10s

I hope you enjoyed my score for "So What."

Stevie · , 10:30 PM

I'm in. But I've got two other rates to vote in as well. I think I can submit within a week but you should probably bump the deadline to Monday the 16th to give people an extra weekend.

Michael · , 4:39 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by Stevie

I'm in. But I've got two other rates to vote in as well. I think I can submit within a week but you should probably bump the deadline to Monday the 16th to give people an extra weekend.

Alright. Well if you or others don't have enough time then I'll push the deadline back a few days.

Quote:

Originally posted by Grenn-O

michael, do you want me to send you my ratings via PM?

Yeah, PM me your ratings.

Quote:

Originally posted by sticks

Oh gosh, I want to participate, but I'll have to properly listen to the first three albums and then brush up on I'm Not Dead, but everything else should be fine.

Please remind me to vote!

I'll post a reminder in this thread daily and send a few wall posts out before the deadline.

Michael · , 6:17 AM

Updated first post with YouTube links to each song.

Underdogs · , 7:15 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by madonnas

Sent!

Averages

My 10/10s

I hope you enjoyed my score for "So What."

Sis how can you NOT give 'Misery' a 10

Ace Reject · , 9:41 AM

Michael, I thought you were just rating her singles.

I'll allow this though!

Great Username · , 9:53 AM

Yeah I would have taken part if it was just singles... Ain't nobody got time for this. Sorry.

Michael · 2:32 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Ace Reject

Michael, I thought you were just rating her singles.

I'll allow this though!

Sorry about that. It'll give people a chance to get themselves ready for the new album I suppose.

madonnas · , 1:53 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Underdogs

Sis how can you NOT give 'Misery' a 10

Wasn't the biggest fan of it

I gave it a 6.

Michael · , 10:59 AM

Is everyone happy with the deadline set?

chilicheese01 · , 11:00 AM

I've only listened to I'm Not Dead...