[tcweh]

Which 2002 Classic Ballad is better?

[All Guns Blazing]

Beautiful

[CoolestPerson12]

Beautiful. It has a stronger message. The songs don't even compare in subject matter.

[ToMmY]

I like both songs but IWY >>>>>>>>>>>

[Underdogs]

IWY>>>>>>>>

[Chunk]

Beautiful is far more iconic, known and successful than the other. Personal opinion or not, those are facts and my personal vote goes to Beautiful.

[tcweh]

Originally posted by Chunk

Beautiful is far more iconic, known and successful than the other. Personal opinion or not, those are facts and my personal vote goes to Beautiful.

I'm With You Went Platinum

[Chunk]

Originally posted by tcweh

I'm With You Went Platinum

Beautiful went #1 in several countries and peaked higher than IWY.

[Changes]

I'm With You.

I always found Beautiful to be a tad bit overrated. It's a nice song, but it's not even close to being one of Christina's best.

[Peep Show]

Beautiful.

[Kang.]

Beautiful.

I'm With You is not very good.

[emmanuel_punk]

'I'm With You' without a doubt

[Maneater]

Originally posted by ClassicMainstream

I'm With You.

I always found Beautiful to be a tad bit overrated. It's a nice song, but it's not even close to being one of Christina's best.

This. I very strongly dislike 'Beautiful'.

IWY is perfect.

[TheCircle94]

I'm With You

[Phoenix83]

I'm With You may well be Avril's best song. It was the one that showed she wasn't just a skater punk but had great ballads and appeal to older listeners. It's also simply an awesome emotive track.

[caleb.]

The one remixed by Rihanna

[Gossip_Boy]

I'm With You.

[UnusualBoy]

Beautiful

[ttsmu]

I'm With You >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

[gabrielmm]

difficult one!

Linda Perry was a genius in the lyrics of Beautiful...
I'm with you is equally touching.