They are sometimes very similar when sounding angry in their last studio albums. And I think they are quite on the same par vocally.
φNightflight - Kate Miller-Heidke = Best Album of 2012 along with Born to Dieφ
ϟ been a Little Monster since 2008 when the Fame wasnt even out ϟ
△ stole a promotional Born This Way poster of a CD Shop in a big crowded mall △
LADY GAGA
Honey B AZEALIA BANKS Delta Goodrem CHER Norah Jones Kate Miller-Heidke Mimi Amy Winehouse Karise Eden JoJo KATE BUSH Ashanti Gwen Stefani Kat McPheeLana Del Rey Lights Regina SpektorJessie James Lily Allen Kimbra Shontelle MIKA Stefanie Heinzmann
I'd say that Pink has a tiny bit more versatility when it comes to her discography, but Gaga's discography is only 3 albums in and she has some gems that are just really really good vocal wise. I'll go with Gaga but Pink is for sure one of the most underrated pop stars of our generation. Gaga had that same kind of rasp Pink did when she first started as well *probably from drugs*
I'd say that Pink has a tiny bit more versatility when it comes to her discography, but Gaga's discography is only 3 albums in and she has some gems that are just really really good vocal wise. I'll go with Gaga but Pink is for sure one of the most underrated pop stars of our generation. Gaga had that same kind of rasp Pink did when she first started as well *probably from drugs*
Do you mean versatility in their voices ?
φNightflight - Kate Miller-Heidke = Best Album of 2012 along with Born to Dieφ
ϟ been a Little Monster since 2008 when the Fame wasnt even out ϟ
△ stole a promotional Born This Way poster of a CD Shop in a big crowded mall △
LADY GAGA
Honey B AZEALIA BANKS Delta Goodrem CHER Norah Jones Kate Miller-Heidke Mimi Amy Winehouse Karise Eden JoJo KATE BUSH Ashanti Gwen Stefani Kat McPheeLana Del Rey Lights Regina SpektorJessie James Lily Allen Kimbra Shontelle MIKA Stefanie Heinzmann
φNightflight - Kate Miller-Heidke = Best Album of 2012 along with Born to Dieφ
ϟ been a Little Monster since 2008 when the Fame wasnt even out ϟ
△ stole a promotional Born This Way poster of a CD Shop in a big crowded mall △
LADY GAGA
Honey B AZEALIA BANKS Delta Goodrem CHER Norah Jones Kate Miller-Heidke Mimi Amy Winehouse Karise Eden JoJo KATE BUSH Ashanti Gwen Stefani Kat McPheeLana Del Rey Lights Regina SpektorJessie James Lily Allen Kimbra Shontelle MIKA Stefanie Heinzmann
Both are among the top of performers. Both are remarkably strong in the vocal department. But I'm going to be realistic. P!nk has been the most consistent with her performances. She has a slight upper edge over Gaga.
Yeah I put discography but my bad. I'm tired. Pink has done some real R&B and her voice is really versatile and it shines best when she does up beat pop rock. Gaga's voice is suitable for jazzy tones and pop, but she can be constricted when it comes to belting notes. (even though she's had times where she has belted amazingly... See Born This Way at Norton Graham)
Yeah I put discography but my bad. I'm tired. Pink has done some real R&B and her voice is really versatile and it shines best when she does up beat pop rock. Gaga's voice is suitable for jazzy tones and pop, but she can be constricted when it comes to belting notes. (even though she's had times where she has belted amazingly... See Born This Way at Norton Graham)
Hmm.. GaGa has done some R&B as well. . Just that she couldn't release them because her music and image has been restricted to Pop and Dance. But She has done more Jazz than P!nk. Is it just me or P!nk has never done any jazz number.
You and I sounds perfectly in jazz.
φNightflight - Kate Miller-Heidke = Best Album of 2012 along with Born to Dieφ
ϟ been a Little Monster since 2008 when the Fame wasnt even out ϟ
△ stole a promotional Born This Way poster of a CD Shop in a big crowded mall △
LADY GAGA
Honey B AZEALIA BANKS Delta Goodrem CHER Norah Jones Kate Miller-Heidke Mimi Amy Winehouse Karise Eden JoJo KATE BUSH Ashanti Gwen Stefani Kat McPheeLana Del Rey Lights Regina SpektorJessie James Lily Allen Kimbra Shontelle MIKA Stefanie Heinzmann
Hmm.. GaGa has done some R&B as well. . Just that she couldn't release them because her music and image has been restricted to Pop and Dance. But She has done more Jazz than P!nk. Is it just me or P!nk has never done any jazz number.
You and I sounds perfectly in jazz.
She hasn't done jazz. Only this jazzy cover of Summertime but this wasnt serious. A spontaneous thing.
But P!nk has done Pop, Rock, Dance, Punk, Country, Electronica, Hip-Hop, Jazz, Urban, R&B, Soul, Rap etc etc.
She's THE most versatile pop singer in the game right now
Hmm.. GaGa has done some R&B as well. . Just that she couldn't release them because her music and image has been restricted to Pop and Dance. But She has done more Jazz than P!nk. Is it just me or P!nk has never done any jazz number.
You and I sounds perfectly in jazz.
I don't think Pink has done jazz (I could be wrong). And that's true there were some R&B demos from Gaga, but they still center in the realm of pop ballads. More of something like RIhanna? If you get what i'm saying. But I think vocally Gaga has surpassed Pink by just a bit, especially when you hear her sing songs like TEOG/Hair live on a piano. Howard Stern anyone?
She hasn't done jazz. Only this jazzy cover of Summertime but this wasnt serious. A spontaneous thing.
But P!nk has done Pop, Rock, Dance, Punk, Country, Electronica, Hip-Hop, Jazz, Urban, R&B, Soul, Rap etc etc.
She's THE most versatile pop singer in the game right now
GaGa has done all except Punk which is I'm not even sure.
Have you listened to GaGa before she blew up.. She has even rapped.
φNightflight - Kate Miller-Heidke = Best Album of 2012 along with Born to Dieφ
ϟ been a Little Monster since 2008 when the Fame wasnt even out ϟ
△ stole a promotional Born This Way poster of a CD Shop in a big crowded mall △
LADY GAGA
Honey B AZEALIA BANKS Delta Goodrem CHER Norah Jones Kate Miller-Heidke Mimi Amy Winehouse Karise Eden JoJo KATE BUSH Ashanti Gwen Stefani Kat McPheeLana Del Rey Lights Regina SpektorJessie James Lily Allen Kimbra Shontelle MIKA Stefanie Heinzmann
I don't think Pink has done jazz (I could be wrong). And that's true there were some R&B demos from Gaga, but they still center in the realm of pop ballads. More of something like RIhanna? If you get what i'm saying. But I think vocally Gaga has surpassed Pink by just a bit, especially when you hear her sing songs like TEOG/Hair live on a piano. Howard Stern anyone?
Last Post
Actions 
Closed Thread
Thread Starter
5/28/2012
I put discography but my bad. I'm tired. Pink has done some real R&B and her voice is really versatile and it shines best when she does up beat pop rock. Gaga's voice is suitable for jazzy tones and pop, but she can be constricted when it comes to belting notes. (even though she's had times where she has belted amazingly... See Born This Way at Norton Graham)
