[Miles.]

Tisdale can sing and act and is way hotter.

[Underdogs]

Tisdale

[Great Username]

"I walked a thousand miles when everyone was asleep"

Ashley never has and never will write lyrics like Ashlee, whose songwriting has been compared to Bob Dylan's by journalists.

[Underdogs]

Originally posted by Great Username

"I walked a thousand miles when everyone was asleep"

Ashley never has and never will write lyrics like Ashlee, whose songwriting has been compared to Bob Dylan's by journalists.

Ashlee is definitely a much better songwriter than Ashley but Bob Dylan

[787dreamliner]

Little Miss Obsessive ***** really hard , so I will go with ASHLEE

[EdR]

ASHLEE all the way!

[Aram]

Clearly, Simpson!

[izzy]

Tisdale

[All Guns Blazing]

Simpson

[notmyselftonight]

Ashley Tisdale. <3

[UnusualBoy]

Ashlee

Catch Me When I Fall, L.O.V.E >>>>

But I like Ashley too

[ddeizaguirre]

Ashlee ****in Simpson>>>>>

Her debut album shat on my life eternally

[KarlosVzla]

Not a Lindsay fan bashing Ashlee for her lypsync incident

Ashlee, of course. I love my princess Tisdale too<3

[PopBoi]

Guilty Pleasure is better than anything Ashlee has put out. Simpson's material is very weak imho.

[conseeded]

Tisdale and it's not even close.

[Strangergab]

Originally posted by PopBoi

Guilty Pleasure is better than anything Ashlee has put out. Simpson's material is very weak imho.

Autobiography>>>>>>>>>

[IVY]

Ashlee Simpson

[PopBoi]

Originally posted by Strangergab

Autobiography>>>>>>>>>

Sorry for having an opinion. Ashlee is the pits.

[Underdogs]

Originally posted by PopBoi

Guilty Pleasure is better than anything Ashlee has put out. Simpson's material is very weak imho.

[~ joão.]

Originally posted by Midnight

Ashlee Simpson and it's not even close.

.