[ManDown]

Ugh, guys. THIS is where I got the list from: http://atrl.net/forums/memberlist.ph...t=posts&pp=100

I literally copied and pasted it. I didn't leave people off because I didn't like them. You guys just don't post enough.

[Sunderland 4ever]

Originally posted by kingsatellites.

Okay and when we return ours don't get high and mighty like you tend to do when people return the favor.

I'll probably be busy and tired anyway. Go ahead.

[ManDown]

Originally posted by Katie

Some currently banned members are not gonna be listed because of the time of tracking

I bet it sucks to be them right now.

[i spit on haters]

Originally posted by kingsatellites.

Okay and when we return ours don't get high and mighty like you tend to do when people return the favor.

oop.

[Katie]

Originally posted by Kin

Ugh, guys. THIS is where I got the list from: http://atrl.net/forums/memberlist.ph...t=posts&pp=100

I literally copied and pasted it. I didn't leave people off because I didn't like them. You guys just don't post enough.

Or they could do their own: http://atrl.net/forums/showthread.php?t=104347

[ManDown]

Originally posted by Katie

Or they could do their own: http://atrl.net/forums/showthread.php?t=104347

Ugh, I miss THAT thread so much. I designed the weekly charts on it when I was still an irrelevant newbie.

[Sunderland 4ever]

Originally posted by Katie

Or they could do their own: http://atrl.net/forums/showthread.php?t=104347

That thread had a lot of potential, but it took a lot of work.

[Katie]

Originally posted by Kin

Ugh, I miss THAT thread so much. I designed the weekly charts on it when I was still an irrelevant newbie.

You did?

I made #20...somehow

[satellites.™]

Oooh this reminds me of Aces 100 most essential members list.

[ManDown]

Originally posted by Sunderland 4ever

That thread had a lot of potential, but it took a lot of work.

It did, for everybody involved. Deemy had to spend hours averaging out all of the scores, and I had to spend hours adding them all onto a PSD file in Photoshop. It would have worked out better if it was a monthly chart versus a weekly thing.

Originally posted by Katie

You did?

I made #20...somehow

Yes.

I debuted and peaked at #15, and then we quit doing it.

By the way, if anybody does want to bring it back, and has Deemy's permission, I'd be willing to send the modifiable files for the chart. I still have them on my computer.

[mons†er]

Originally posted by kingsatellites.

Oooh this reminds me of Aces 100 most essential members list.

Sis you should do one

[skyler]

Originally posted by kingsatellites.

Oooh this reminds me of Aces 100 most essential members list.

i wonder will i make that list, i think he hates me though

[satellites.™]

Originally posted by Katie

Or they could do their own: http://atrl.net/forums/showthread.php?t=104347

Sam cheated.

I was supposed to debut at #1.

[ManDown]

Originally posted by kingsatellites.

Oooh this reminds me of Aces 100 most essential members list.

It's similar to that, minus the whole ranking based on relevancy/"legacy" and whatnot. This is simply a ranking of how well-liked/respected/popular a member is based on the top 100 posters. I thought that it would be easier and more fair to just use the already compiled list of the top 100 posters versus picking people myself.

[ManDown]

I wonder when Ace will remake the Essential Members list again, by the way. It's been a long time, and there would definitely be some jumps and drops on the list, as well as new entries.

[Sunderland 4ever]

Originally posted by Kin

I wonder when Ace will remake the Essential Members list again, by the way. It's been a long time, and there would definitely be some jumps and drops on the list, as well as new entries.

The magic of a ranking like that is that it was done 11 years after the creation of ATRL. In order to keep that magic, it would be great if it is done by the time ATRL turns 15 years.

[Red]

Originally posted by Kin

I wonder when Ace will remake the Essential Members list again, by the way. It's been a long time, and there would definitely be some jumps and drops on the list, as well as new entries.

And TC would still be #1. As it should be.

[ManDown]

Originally posted by Sunderland 4ever

The magic of a ranking like that is that it was done 11 years after the creation of ATRL. In order to keep that magic, it would be great if it is done by the time ATRL turns 15 years.

True. If it was done yearly, it may defeat the purpose. But something along the lines of once every two years would work.

[Sunderland 4ever]

Originally posted by Childish Redbino

And TC would still be #1. As it should be.

I agree. The top 20 would barely move.

[Katie]