[superben]

Umbrella, definitely.

[Cas]

Umbrella in 2007 >>>>>> We Found Love in 2011 When Umbrella was still new to me, it was THE song at the time.

[SLAYANNA NAVY]

Originally posted by Jaymz

I don't get why people are actually voting for WFL as her CAREER DEFINING SONG... They fail to realise that if Rihanna hadn't released Umbrella then we would never have gotten We Found Love because she wouldn't have been as successful as she is right now

TELL EM

[potentbreakupsong]

Umbrella. Her best song.

[KoreanDream]

Umbrella. But WFL is a better song.

[notmyselftonight]

Umbrella.

[Fruity]

I see I voted for Umbrella. Because of the OP saying "career defining".

Umbrella will never lose that.

I actually prefer WFL though.

[RatedG²]

Umbrella easily

[iheartBrit]

Umbrella is her career-defining hit but I prefer WFL.