[Quiqui4eva]

Both

[Ghandi]

I'm in the middle.

Both songs are pretty iconic in their own right and massively catchy. Even now anyone who knows the slightest bit about pop music has heard or knows these songs.

[DrunkNHotBoyz]

This is hard, but I'ma go with "I Want It That Way". That song really captures that whole TRL era and everything.

[Glam]

I liked BSB's song better but Byex3 is pretty cool too.

[andresg770]

I like both, but "I Want It That Way" is such a karaoke classic!! Every time I go to a karaoke bar someone's singing that song; typically a couple of drunk girls (), so I voted for that, even though the BSB have way better songs.

However, if we wanna talk the video, "Bye Bye Bye" (and 'N Sync's discography from the No Strings Attached and Celebrity eras) >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

[emmanuel_punk]

love BOTH!

but I Want It That Way is ICONIC and so LEGENDARY so yeah I go for that one.

[Patrick]

IWITW is about as close to pop perfection as one can get.

[Lemón]

But, where's Duca?

This just won't do.

[Duca]

Originally posted by The New York Times

The 7,500 Most Important Songs of 1944-2000
#24 *NSYNC Bye Bye Bye
#88 Backstreet Boys I Want It That Way

Originally posted by VH1

The 100 Greatest Songs of the 2000s
#36 *NSYNC Bye Bye Bye
#61 Backstreet Boys I Want It That Way

"I Want It That Way" is lyrically developmentally disabled. The opening line is great. The first verse is good. "That way" sounds intriguing. Then the chorus kicks in. The guy is wondering why the relationship is hard and feels like a mistake, but then sings about never wanting her to "want it that way" after trying to convince her to believe him that he "wants it that way." Like, what the hell? I still have no idea what’s the "that way" he wants. Is "that way" a good or a bad thing? Is it anal sex? The bouncing up n’ down and arm swinging they call dancing in the music video, in addition to the airplane with their name on it and the fans wearing their tour shirts always makes me laugh. So do the performances.

"Bye Bye Bye" is an undeniable pop classic, an iconic song with an iconic video and iconic performance. The video debuted at #1 on TRL and eventually spent 53 days at #1.

[Icannot]

I cannot choose.

[Duca]

Originally posted by Esoteric Spice

But, where's Duca?

This just won't do.

[superben]

I Want It That Way >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

[Calypso]

I Want It That Way

[PopBoi]

I want it that way >>>

Used to love that song.

[tcweh]

Would of been better comparing 'Everybody' to Bye bye bye, As they are the same style, And i think Everybody was also bigger then IWITW?

[Robert]

IWITW

BSB>>>N'SYNC