[Gui Blackout]

Could any other popstar pull off such a controversial, polemic and groundbreaking era like Erotica, and get away with it? Or Madonna was truly one of the kind?

[misguidedghost]

In this day and age, anything is possible.

[GotMyBlueprint]

Originally posted by misguidedghost

In this day and age, anything is possible.

pretty much

[iamthelaw]

Rihanna

[misguidedghost]

There are MUCH more controversial things in this world, than (if it did happen) Erotica 2.0.
But, I don't see it, living up to it. I see it as a tribute, but never living up to it!

[Callisto.]

But didn't Madonna technically not even pull it off herself?

[CaptainMusic]

Never.

[Gui Blackout]

Originally posted by iBeyoncé.

But didn't Madonna technically not even pull it off herself?

How so?

[Honey]

No.

When this album came out, it was the controversial thing ever done in the music industry. Critics were saying how Madonna's career was over with this album.

[Callisto.]

Originally posted by Gui Blackout

How so?

Wasn't it the Erotica era that put Madonna in critical condition until Ray of Life?
Not saying it ruined her career cause it didn't but it certainly hurt her more than it helped her.

[All Guns Blazing]

No, popstars aren't as fearless as they once were

[EyesOpen]

Nevah. The world is so trashy these days it's not even original to be sensual or a **** anymore.

[Gui Blackout]

Originally posted by iBeyoncé.

Wasn't the Erotica era that put Madonna in critical condition until Ray of Life?
Not saying it ruined her career cause it didn't but it certainly hurt her more than it helped her.

But that's my point, she was crucified but then recovered perfectly well, it didn't hurt her longevity and legacy. I don't think anyone else would get away after something like that.

[Travis Bickle]

Never. Nobody as Madonna. Nobody can equalize it. that was unique!

And now is remember as one of their best eras!

[Belle]

It's not shocking anymore.

[Gui Blackout]

Originally posted by Belle

It's not shocking anymore.

Really? You think if someone released the Sex Book today it wouldn't shock the society?

[Oxidane]

Originally posted by Gui Blackout

Really? You think if someone released the Sex Book today it wouldn't shock the society?

Obviously it would, but the feeling of shock would quickly dissipate as people start to compare it to what Madonna did + how she was the first pop star to release one.

[madonnas]

Originally posted by EyesOpen

Nevah. The world is so trashy these days it's not even original to be sensual or a **** anymore.

And I can't tell the future, but out of this crop of Pop stars, none of them really seem to care about pushing sexuality on the forefront like Madonna did then. Don't give me none of that Talk that Talk ******** either.

[ashuduff]

Originally posted by iamthelaw

Rihanna

No

[TheGeoKing]

No.

Just like no one could pull of a Ray of Light era.