[EdgeOfAddiction]

2005 had such great music that it was such a battle to get a #1. Boulevard of Broken Dreams and Since U Been Gone most certainly deserved a #1. As did Pon De Replay and Bad Romance. These were flawless songs that were snubbed so hard.

[csybeyking]

Bad Romance really didn't deserve #2 as much as.people say it did

[Cap10Planet]

At least "Work It" was blocked by an equally great song - "Lose Yourself," but it still irks me that the song failed to get a week at #1. They should have rotated the way J. Lo and Alicia Keys did in 2001.

[Honey]

Originally posted by EdgeOfAddiction

2005 had such great music that it was such a battle to get a #1. Boulevard of Broken Dreams and Since U Been Gone most certainly deserved a #1. As did Pon De Replay and Bad Romance. These were flawless songs that were snubbed so hard.

The first two were blocked by Candy Shop, by 50 Cent.

PdR was blocked by We Belong Together.

I think Bad Romance was blocked by a Black Eyed Peas song?

Can't Let Go, Loverboy, and Shake It Off by Mariah deserved to be #1.




All 6 of Madonna's #2 hits deserved #1.

[Mattyboy]

As for my vote.. I'm going with Party in the U.S.A.

A Dr. Luke masterpiece.

Does anyone remember which song blocked it?

[Cap10Planet]

"Bad Romance" was blocked by Jay-Z and Ke$ha, right?

[MusicTalker]

Success-wise, Dynamite.

Personal taste, Bad Romance.

[Luigi]

Bad Romance.
Where's Beautiful?

[csybeyking]

Originally posted by Mattyboy

As for my vote.. I'm going with Party in the U.S.A.

A Dr. Luke masterpiece.

Does anyone remember which song blocked it?

I Gotta Feeling and Boom Boom Pow

BR was blocked by ESOM and TT

[NewRihannaStan]

Bad Romance derserved number one it was a freaking massive song

[IREPMINAJ]

what the bloody **** idk Bad Romance didnt make it to 1# !!?!?!!?!? as much as i heard that dope song on the radio smh damn shame ...now what song blocked that smash from 1#

[stereo.love]

Oh and any song by Janet that peaked at #2 should have went #1. She would hold the record for most #1s from an album I think.

[KittyCat]

Party In The Usa deserved #1.

[Mickey]

How has no one mentioned Apologise by OneRepublic?

[CriticalHit]

Leaving out one of the biggest smashes of the past decade, aka Since U Been Gone, isn't cute.

[Cap10Planet]

Originally posted by IREPMINAJ

what the bloody **** idk Bad Romance didnt make it to 1# !!?!?!!?!? as much as i heard that dope song on the radio smh damn shame ...now what song blocked that smash from 1#

I'm pretty sure it was "Empire State of Mind" (6 weeks @ #1) and "Tik Tok" (9 weeks @ #1).

[Honey]

Originally posted by IREPMINAJ

what the bloody **** idk Bad Romance didnt make it to 1# !!?!?!!?!? as much as i heard that dope song on the radio smh damn shame ...now what song blocked that smash from 1#

Empire State of Mind, which is MUCH better than BR.

And TiK ToK, which is slightly better than BR.

BR didn't deserve #1, tbh.

[UnusualBoy]

TSE didn't top the chart? life ain't worthy!!

[JakeHouser]

BAD ROMANCE.

[Honey]

Originally posted by CriticalHit

Leaving out one of the biggest smashes of the past decade, aka Since U Been Gone, isn't cute.

Most people on ATRL don't care about music prior to 2008, because that's when their fave arrived on the scene (except for Beyhive and Navy).