ATRL - Discussion: Living Life Like it's Golden Rate:FINAL 3

ImpressiveInstant · , 10:07 PM

American Pie is a 9.5

If you guys really wanted to eliminate two Madonna songs now, at least they should've been Amazing and Runaway Lover. Not these.

fortheloveofmusic · , 10:10 PM

#40
"Baby"
6.143
Highest Score -8.5 Lowest Score-3 (2X)

Don't expect this pattern to continue

This disco-dance bop shouldn't have been this low in my opinion. The song is a great example of the sound of "Fever." The catchy chorus alone should of been enough to push it to top 30, but I digress.

Ace Reject · , 10:11 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by fortheloveofmusic

#40
"Baby"
6.143
Highest Score -8.5 Lowest Score-3 (2X)

Don't expect this pattern to continue

This disco-dance bop shouldn't have been this low in my opinion. The song is a great example of the sound of "Fever." The catchy chorus alone should of been enough to push it to top 30, but I digress.

Right?!?! It's so discoey! Kylie's always best when surrounded by rhythm.

madonnas · , 10:12 PM

Was I the 8.5??? I remember really liking this.

supaspaz · , 10:15 PM

An electro-psychedelic cover of "American Pie" was definitely an odd choice for Madonna. Fortunately, the original is so great that her version can't be terrible.

madonnas · , 10:22 PM

I keep on listening to this track over and over. I really should have given it a 10

I'm appalled.

adrianbeane · , 2:56 AM

I'm totally OK with all the eliminations so far. Nothing really interesting has left so everything is alright. Hopefully more Janet filler sexjams will leave next time 'round.

Janelle Monáe · , 8:24 AM

Love scene shouldn't have been out so early

Quote:

Originally posted by madonnas

It's not that bad

but for the only 2 times in this rate I didn't give Madonna a 10.

How many 10's did you give overall????

I only gave 1

Praise Mariallah · , 11:54 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by supaspaz

An electro-psychedelic cover of "American Pie" was definitely an odd choice for Madonna. Fortunately, the original is so great that her version can't be terrible.

I agree with this. I gave American Pie a 10, but it was mostly because I can't shake the fondness I have of the original

Praise Mariallah · , 11:56 AM

Baby got a 6.5 from me, and Boy got a 5. So far it seems my numbers are very on the mark in relation to the averages

madonnas · , 11:57 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by Pink Panther

Love scene shouldn't have been out so early

How many 10's did you give overall????

I only gave 1

I gave 20 10s, I think.

I usually am harsher but I just love giving Madonna 10s so if she's in the rate I just inflate it for everyone.

Praise Mariallah · , 12:01 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by madonnas

I gave 20 10s, I think.

I usually am harsher but I just love giving Madonna 10s so if she's in the rate I just inflate it for everyone.

Change your avi back to the slug, it is iconic

madonnas · , 12:07 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Praise Mariallah

Change your avi back to the slug, it is iconic

I needed a change up, I'll change it back later.

Ace Reject · , 12:13 PM

Personal moment - ten years ago, when I first head Boy, I swore instead of "pretty little thing, making my heart sing," she was singing "Puerto Rican thing, making my heart sing ..."

I prefer it my way.

@michael. · , 12:14 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Ace Reject

Personal moment - ten years ago, when I first head Boy, I swore instead of "pretty little thing, making my heart sing," she was singing "Puerto Rican thing, making my heart sing ..."

I prefer it my way.

Did u have a puerto rican boyfriend?