[Ramcoro]

Originally posted by Monroe

Poker Face, LoveGame, Alejandro, Bad Romance, Paparazzi maybe even Telephone were all better then Edge Of Glory was.

Switch Alejandro and Telephone and add Just Dance, and I will agree with this.

[MonsterConnor]

Originally posted by MusicTalker

Am I also the only one that heard it 10,000 times on the radio?

nope
i heard it numerous times daily throughout june - august
and i still hear it every now and then

in fact the only Gaga songs i hear on radio anymore are Y&I and The Edge

[Cannabis]

It has sold the same as songs like 5 weeks at #1 or 160AI Rude Boy or What's My Name?
The sales weren't bad at all, but yes it deserved more.

[PurrKaty]

Originally posted by WFL

Maybe the boring video caused that.

This, its her only video i can't watch cause it has nothing to it really

[Kieran]

Wasn't Jonas Akerlund supposed to direct it? If he DID then woooow..

[Roberto]

Originally posted by Kieran

Wasn't Jonas Akerlund supposed to direct it? If he DID then woooow..

It was The Haus Of GaGa.

[Christian]

Originally posted by Kieran

Wasn't Jonas Akerlund supposed to direct it? If he DID then woooow..

No, Joseph Kahn who directed LoveGame, was supposed to.

[MonsterConnor]

Originally posted by Christian

No, Joseph Kahn who directed LoveGame, was supposed to.

then gaga and him had disagreements , she wanted a more simple video
blah blah blah

[Stephen]

I really wanted to see that Kahn TEOG video. Sounded like a masterpiece in the making

[Foot]

The fact that the public dislikes her, and the video.

[Kieran]

Originally posted by MonsterConnor

then gaga and him had disagreements , she wanted a more simple video
blah blah blah

worse decision of her career tbh

[Damien M]

I honestly don't know.

I used to hear it all the time on Pop stations.

[LadyGagaStan93]

Originally posted by Vin

In my opinion, the song was not interesting
and was a reductive rehash of the 80's.



...Vin

Radio thought it was interesting so that's not the problem.

[rue005]

Because of Judas probably but it was great for a third single, I'm sure by the time it was released many people already had the album. Anyway, I think TEOG was the best single from BTW era!

[BangBang]

The chorus was kinda eh.. and too repetitive.
The sax was totally out of place and unnecessary.
There u go.

[Benzene]

Bad timing, bad video.

It would've been way more successful had it been released as the 2nd single.

[ddeizaguirre]

Originally posted by BangBang

The chorus was kinda eh.. and too repetitive.
The sax was totally out of place and unnecessary.
There u go.

The chorus and the sax make that song

[ddeizaguirre]

I think some of you underrate the success it had its still successful I hear it on the radio everywhere and many people claim it to be there favorite gaga song of all time and not only on ATRL I'm talking about the GP

[Remixed]

It didn't really deserve too. It's not really catchy, and the radio edit was pretty bad. ~3m in the US is where it should be at

And it has a low replay value

[Monceau]

Yeah that song is better than BTW.