ATRL - Poll: Do you want Britney to Judge on X Factor?

CaptainMusic · , 2:25 PM

Everyday i keep seeing more and more articles about britney and x factor.., Do YOU want her to become a judge on it or not?

Duca · , 2:25 PM

Vulps · , 2:26 PM

That show is a mess. No.

Bad Wolf · , 2:26 PM

Remixed · , 2:26 PM

MovinKindaSlow · , 2:27 PM

Only if Janet is.

Do Ya Thang · , 2:27 PM

No, I just don't feel like it'll be good for her image.

evan93 · , 2:28 PM

i just want her to do something, i don't want her to stay away for a couple of years and then come out of nowhere with a new album

Rentboy · , 2:28 PM

Yes. She's the kind of big name they need. But maybe she'd be too nice? But it'd be interesting to see her in this context.

annashaus · , 2:30 PM

No. And that's because I want what's best for her.

нαυѕσƒנα¢к · , 2:30 PM

N O

Firstly, she's too much of a big artist to be judging on a talent show like X-Factor not to mention it would hurt her image rather than help it like some stans believe. If she isn't open and remains robotic like in her interviews then she won't be a good judge and the public won't see her for who she really is, which we rarely see nowadays. She's too humble and nice to be a judge to give constructive criticism. Not to mention the media + public backlash to her judging others on their singing when she mimes herself.

Bdawg · , 2:31 PM

yes, I would. I think that it's a win win. It gets Xfactor those ratings they want, and it let's Brit break out of her shell and be more comfortable.

The only bad thing is that, that means us fans won't be getting a album out for another year then.

CaptainMusic · , 2:31 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by нαυѕσƒנα¢к

N O

Firstly, she's too much of a big artist to be judging on a talent show like X-Factor not to mention it would hurt her image rather than help it like some stans believe. If she isn't open and remains robotic like in her interviews then she won't be a good judge and the public won't see her for who she really is, which we rarely see nowadays. She's too humble and nice to be a judge to give constructive criticism. Not to mention the media + public backlash to her judging others on their singing when she mimes herself.

Nicely put, and i agree.

madonnas · , 2:33 PM

No, she's been slowly regaining her public integrity. I don't want her to take a step back.

Bdawg · , 2:33 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by нαυѕσƒנα¢к

Not to mention the media + public backlash to her judging others on their singing when she mimes herself.

like I've told you before, in the US they won't care. If it was the UK they would, but all of the headlines already haven't mentioned anything about that.

ImmaSlave4u · , 2:34 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by нαυѕσƒנα¢к

N O

Firstly, she's too much of a big artist to be judging on a talent show like X-Factor not to mention it would hurt her image rather than help it like some stans believe. If she isn't open and remains robotic like in her interviews then she won't be a good judge and the public won't see her for who she really is, which we rarely see nowadays. She's too humble and nice to be a judge to give constructive criticism. Not to mention the media + public backlash to her judging others on their singing when she mimes herself.

Literally 100%

gagakyle · , 2:36 PM

I feel like from an entertainment perspective, it would be good for ratings. But I don't think she'll be able to give much insight to singers. I see her giving feedback similar to Paula, which isn't necessarily a bad thing.