[ALI☊]

If both Actresses/Singers decided to make a big comeback, who would make a bigger one? Who would people be more interested in? In other words, which would have more potential to be "big" again after all these years?





(P.S. let's just believe that Lindsay will be all cleaned up and sober. So take that in consideration)

[cuitrex]

Obviously lindsay cuz her case a much bigger impact.

[XtremeSteel]

Hilary can do it with less effort, but they both could have great comebacks.

[Porygon2z]

anyone, but please just come back

I need them in my life again

[Katy V.!]

Lindsay, she was bigger and she fell harder. People love stories like that.

[ALI☊]

I want new Lindsay music and new Hilary movies. Im sure it's the opposite for most people.

[Crazy Lights]

Lindsay's comeback would be bigger seeing after all she's been through.

[Katie]

If Lindsay were to get her life together, hers would obviously be bigger. There's no denying it. Hilary is more of a guarantee of success, but it wouldn't be nearly as large as Lindsay's story.

Hilary = sure thing, but small success
Lindsay = wildcard, possible large success.

[Nɑɑji.. ©]

Hilary wasn't that big in the first place imo.

Lindsay was on her way to be one of the biggest teen actresses of her time.

So obviously Lindsay.

[Trent]

Originally posted by Katy V.!

Lindsay, she was bigger and she fell harder. People love stories like that.

Really? I had no idea Lindsay sold 13 million albums WW.

[Katie]

Originally posted by Nɑɑji.. ©

Hilary wasn't that big in the first place imo.

Lindsay was on her way to be one of the biggest teen actresses of her time.

So obviously Lindsay.

Lindsay really could have been one of the few people to ever cross over from young Disney to serious Hollywood. It's such a shame.

[KKCuteCat]

Lindsay. As she's still more interesting

[Jaxsin]

Originally posted by Trent

Really? I had no idea Lindsay sold 13 million albums WW.

She doesn't need to sell 13 million albums WW, people are more intersted in Lindsay.

[Rafael]

Hopefully Hillary

[zach]

What about "both" since they are both literally my favs?

[zach]

Originally posted by Trent

Really? I had no idea Lindsay sold 13 million albums WW.

No one's talking about music.

Lindsay is DONE with music, and she was NEVER a teen idol.

Hilary's stopping the acting for a bit and doing music (thank god), and Lindsay is stopping the singing and acting (thank god).

[zach]

Originally posted by ALI☊

I want new Lindsay music and new Hilary movies. Im sure it's the opposite for most people.

Exact opposite for me.

[jacklavigne]

Originally posted by zach

What about "both" since they are both literally my favs?

I would choose both as well, even though Lindsay has never been one of my faves (Hilary was). I think Hilary is better as musician/singer than as actress and Lindsay is better actress than singer. They are both talented in different ways, althought they have a different personality from each other.

Lindsay has a potential to be a really good actress, I really liked her role in Bobby. But she needs to leave her dark years behind FOR GOOD, it won't be easy though, she'll have to work hard to recover her career and respect from general audience; however, people will be looking at her to some how he delivers, a good thing of her. Hilary, on the other hand, has never been "hated" or something like that, but she has been completely irrevelant last 3-4 years, that's where she will have it harder.But she's a hard-worker and talented girl and she's very mature for her age, being already married and about to have a kid.

Anyway, best of lucks for both

[TheEmancipation]

Hilary will find it easier to come back in any sort of way, but If they both comeback, Lindsays comback will be much abigger and BIG.

[Vithor]

What are we talking about here? Movies or music? Movies, I feel like Lindsay cause she's more talented, but on the music field, I'd say Hilary, cause I don't think Lindsay will ever release another album, but I don't think Hilary will have a big hit either.