[caleb]

Rank the girls on their impact on you

[FAN]

We do this topic all the time

They are the Pop/Rock trinity

Kelly > Avril > Pink

but they are all very talented & have amazing disographies! I miss the days when the three used to rule the charts.

[Killer Queen]

Pink > Kelly > Avril.

[Yourfavefan]

Avril wins it for me tbh!

[TheGeoKing]

P!nk

[justaflopstan94]

Kelly > Pink > Avril

Although I love them all, Kelly is just it for me.

[Taigan]

Originally posted by FAN

They are the Pop/Rock trinity

+1

[Mzd]

Kelly>>>Avril>Pink

I love them all though

[Playboy]

Originally posted by iLukey

Pink > Kelly > HELL > Avril.

[Heisenberg]

for me it is Kelly > Pink > Avril but i love all three

Avril's personality kinda brings her down compared to the other two

[Glam]

I love all three almost equally but Kelly has the lead in my opinion.

[ElectricFrancis]

Avril > P!nk >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> >>>>>>>>>>> Kelly.

[Rainer]

Pink > Kelly > Avril

[joelovesmusic]

ALL EPIC! But I'm gonna go with KC

[LolMinaj]

P!nk = Kelly > Avril

I love all 3 though.

[tell_me_a_lie]

I think this was already done before.

The other 2 lovely ladies should release new material this year. Their raw music were totally missed. Please save 2012 from the "generic" music that was flamboyantly used and heard during 2010 and 2011.

[Jdella11]

The Breakaway era >>>

[caleb]

Originally posted by tell_me_a_lie

I think this was already done before.

The other 2 lovely ladies should release new material this year. Their raw music were totally missed. Please save 2012 from the "generic" music that was flamboyantly used and heard during 2010 and 2011.

yes it's been done before

but they don't put together the pop rock trinity

they just did Avril vs Kelly
and Avril vs Pink

[Mzd]

Kelly Avril and Pink are THE pop/rock trinity

Those pics that were added in the OP

[MusicLoverDude]

Avril was the first artist I ever stanned for and my love for her has always been the strongest. My vote goes to her! She was the first artist that i had purchased all the albums of completely, and she has had the most year-end #1 singles in my lists. Complicated, My Happy Ending, and Girlfriend were my favorite songs of 2002, 2004, and 2007 respectively.

I love Kelly and P!nk too of course. I stanned for Kelly's Breakaway era, and I dived right into Never Again and Miss Independent when they were released. But I lost interest with her most recent two albums. They just don't have as great epic quality as Breakaway. All the singles off AIEW are forgettable, but Don't Let Me Stop You and If I Can't Have You are total gems. Stronger is forgettable too, especially Mr. Know It All. But What Doesn't Kill You has been Kelly's strongest single in my opinion since Never Again, and the song Einstein is also quite a gem!

P!nk's eras have generally been a lot stronger than Kelly's in consistancy. Misunderstood had EPIC singles all around. In fact, P!nk's only relatively bad era was Try This. Trouble and God Is a DJ though are standouts.

I'm Not Dead and Funhouse however have to be her best albums in my opinion. I like almost all the songs in those albums. Who Knew became my ultimate favorite P!nk song. So What was also a really great track and I'm glad it was a #1 hit!

So in my standings here's how it goes.

Avril - 10/10
P!nk 9/10
Kelly 8/10

None of these girls are anything less of legendary.

But, you left out the fourth girl of the pop rock era - Ashlee Simpson.