[Nicole]

Originally posted by supaspaz

"Secret" is top ten material. Like, no question, it's one of Madonna's best songs ever. That eliminations sucks.

[madonnas]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

Yeah, Survival gives you that bop AND something to sing along to. Even Don't Stop would have made a bigger and better single than Human Nature.

Ugh. Late ******s never prosper. This rate is proof of that.

People were never here for hip-hop madonna, but that doesn't mean it's not a good song. Bedtime Story also flopped but it's one of the best 90s singles of all time.

[ImpressiveInstant]

These are my most played Madonna songs:

1. Don't Tell Me
2. Secret
3. Erotica
4. Vogue
5. Jump
6. Ray of Light
7. Human Nature
8. American Life
9. La Isla Bonita
10. Die Another Day

5 of them made the Top 20. Two made the Top 10.

[Bathomet]

noooo... Secret.

[supaspaz]

Originally posted by ImpressiveInstant

Two made the Top 10.

I really want it to be "Don't Tell Me" and "Ray of Light," but I have a feeling it's "Ray of Light" and "Vogue."

[bobbymfw]

The only redeeming qualities to "Human Nature" are the sinister beat and the hilarious lyric, "Oops! I didn't know we couldn't talk about sex!" It's a great swagger anthem, but not really a great song. Same goes for "Erotica." At least the video for this one was killer though.

[Americano]

Secret and Holiday didn't make top 10. This thread is void.

[Icing]

I LOVE that Drowned World is still there. I gave it a ten.

But Human Nature?

[Jameson Teqkilla]

Survival AND Human Nature are my faves. Stop pitting then against each other, ACE.

[Icing]

This would be my ideal top ten:

Like a Prayer
Vogue
Into the Groove
Don't Tell Me
Papa Don't Preach
Hung Up
Open Your Heart
Ray of Light
Get Together
Drowned World

Drowned World and Get Together don't have a chance though.

[@michael.]

Originally posted by ImpressiveInstant

#24 - HOLIDAY
Average: 8.5556 - Highest: 10 (x11), Lowest: 5 (x2)

Writers: Curtis Hudson, Lisa Stevens
Producer: John "Jellybean" Benitez

The producer (Benitez) discovered this song, written by a group called Pop Energy, and offered it to Madonna, since it had been already turned down by other artists. They re-produced the song, in order to increase its commercial appeal. It was released as a single and managed to be Madonna's first hit, reaching #16 in the US and #6 in the UK. Later, it was re-released in the UK and it peaked at #2.

Madonna performed "Holiday" in all of her tours, except one - The Confessions Tour. The picture above is from the Blond Ambition performance, which is really worth the watch.

No video was made for it, but later some performances were used as its videos.

This is really classic Madonna. If "Justify My Love" is the definition of sexy, this is the definition of happiness. 9.5 from me.

Originally posted by ImpressiveInstant

#23 - LIVE TO TELL
Average: 8.5694 - Highest: 10 (x12), Lowest: 5 (x2)

Writers: Madonna, Patrick Leonard
Producers: Madonna, Patrick Leonard

During the recording of True Blue, Patrick Leonard was writing a theme for some random Paramount film, but ultimately they ended up rejecting it. Then he showed it to Madonna - she decided to use it for Sean's film At Close Range, and wrote the lyrics for it.

It was released as the lead single off True Blue, and it was a success - it was her third US #1, and it peaked at #2 in the UK. It also reached the top 10s of many countries.

She performed it live at The Who's That Girl Tour, The Blond Ambition Tour and The Confessions Tour - in the latter, she performed it hanging on a cross, which caused some controversy over the show.

Its video shows Madonna wearing a more mature look and singing "Live to Tell" in a dark room, while some scenes from At Close Range are shown.

For me, this is Madonna's best ballad. 10.

What the ****ing ****ety-****er ****????

YOU WILL ALL BURN

[@michael.]

Well, now that a few of my 10s have been murdered, my Top 10 has changed a bit.

1. The Power of Good-Bye
2. Like a Prayer
3. Get Together
4. Vogue
5. Hung Up
6. Deeper and Deeper
7. Ray of Light
8. Like a Virgin
9. Papa Don't Preach
10. Music

I expect TPOGB & Deeper and Deeper to be murdered pretty soon as well.

[dinorel]

Ohhh yeah, I'm so fcking happy the only two 10s I gave have made into the top 20

[LittleDreamer]

Wow. Secret, Live To Tell, Justify My Love and La Isla Bonita Gone

[Jameson Teqkilla]

Impressive, can you send my rates back to me so I can see what I gave a 10 again?

[DeathRevisited]

Secret should have been in the Top 10.

[Navin]

Oh **** y'all for the BLASPHEMY of Secret/Justify My Love rankings. Both deserved Top 10 spots.
Oh and La Isla bonita should still be here too.

[@michael.]

So how far are we going tonight?

[ImpressiveInstant]

Originally posted by @michael.

So how far are we going tonight?

I think I'll give you #20 - #16 tonight.

[@michael.]

Originally posted by ImpressiveInstant

I think I'll give you #20 - #16 tonight.

Can't wait!