[Gagasm]

Since the word 'Iconic" gets thrown around so much(by stans at least), I would like to find out what's really "Iconic" and what's not.

Every round or so I will put something up, everyone will discuss whether its iconic or not, and we'll move on.

Feel Free To Explain Yourself, this isn't a voting thread.

Round 2: Is The 4 Era Iconic?

Previous Rounds

Round 1: Is The Born This Way Era Iconic?

[Remixed]

yes

[Killer Queen]

No.

[Nyx]

Of course.

[TheOnlyOne]

Nope.

[FreeBitch]

NO.

[letscauseascene1]

It will be forgettable, and known for her tacky .99 ploy than anything TBH.

[Calypso]

Yes.

[alkralkra]

As much as I love Gaga, not really.

[MonsterMosama]

Yes. By far her most iconic era- and the most iconic era of the year regardless of how much recent success marrythefanswhowillleavemeafter1singleflops receives.

[Darren-5-08]

Yes. Whether you think so for good reasons or for bad reasons, people aren't going to forget this era in a hurry.

[Immaculate_Lamb]

No

[Christian]

Yes, in ten years when you pull up her discography of maybe six or seven albums, Born This Way will still stand out. Its tracks - debut single, especially - its Grammy nomination, its fashion, even the missteps in this era will be remembered.

[fineandbambi]

No. The BTW era has been a blur. Honestly the only thing I remember about it is Rick Genest.

[Amaru]

I don't know.... Sure. Why not.

[inspiration4]

of course

[Alberto]

Originally posted by letscauseascene1

It will be forgettable, and known for her tacky .99 ploy than anything TBH.

The same they said bout the Beatles 'Revolver', that it was ****, and look now how its praised. By the way, the comparison is fair. Tony Bennet said she was the next Elvis Presley

[MrMinum]

NO.

[Patri]

No, it's inconsistent and lacks a central theme that is tangible in the videos/songs/performances like her previous eras.

[Fadicuss]

Yes. It will not be forgetten anytime soon. Ton of #1s =/= iconic.

But still, TFM is still way more iconic than the BTW era.