ATRL - ATRL: Album/Singles/Artist Rates - Interested? Sign Up and Discuss

genetic fail · , 9:14 PM

Is someone already doing this?
1) 2008 Mega-Rate: One of the Boys v. Circus v. Fearless v. The Fame v. Funhouse v. I Am ... Sasha Fierce

Ill be more than willing to!

RatedG² · , 9:42 PM

The Voice...a rate of all 18 number 1s

Love the title

Nait Phoenix · , 9:51 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Shape

I'm setting some ground rules for my singles rate.

#1: The #1 has to be from a woman who is alligned in the pop world. This means no Ashanti, Ciara, etc. Beyonce is pop to me, so she's a go ahead. I'm debating Alicia Keys' inclusion in this.
#2: The woman on said #1 must be the lead artist. If it's an equal sharing song, there can't be more than 2 people. If there are features, there can't be more than two either (producers don't count)
#3: "Urban" sounding #1s are ok if the artist has been proven to be a "pop" alligned star (ie: Baby Boy and JLo's #1s are ok by me)
#4. The song must have gone #1 between the beginning of January 2000 and the end of November 2011.

EDIT: Oh and I'm not including American Idol #1s. Sorry. This includes Moment Like This

Any questions or comments? Because I'm compiling my list of #1s right now

EDIT 2: There are 56 #1s. This includes Alicia Keys. I'm still not including Ciara or Ashanti.

So, yeah, I'm definitely not participating in that single rate.

Shapes · , 9:56 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Nait Phoenix

So, yeah, I'm definitely not participating in that single rate.

Seriously? Over two artists who aren't even close to pop music?

Well, I'd rather not have LoversThing try to drag me again, so maybe I'll just include them.

That's only 2 extra songs anyway

Venus · , 10:17 PM

Ace this is like the third delay I've gotten.

Ace Reject · , 11:08 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Venus

Ace this is like the third delay I've gotten.

I was not expecting Keir to get back from banland so soon! He threw everything off.

If you want, since yours won't be as ... heavily populated as the rest, you can start next Monday. Cyber Monday.

genetic fail · , 11:22 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by genetic fail

Is someone already doing this?
1) 2008 Mega-Rate: One of the Boys v. Circus v. Fearless v. The Fame v. Funhouse v. I Am ... Sasha Fierce

Ill be more than willing to!

*bump*

Nait Phoenix · , 11:41 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Shape

Seriously? Over two artists who aren't even close to pop music?

Well, I'd rather not have LoversThing try to drag me again, so maybe I'll just include them.

That's only 2 extra songs anyway

There has to be a reason they made the top Hot 100.

Ace Reject · , 11:47 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by genetic fail

*bump*

Unfortunately, Duca claimed that rate!

@michael. · , 9:46 AM

If "Live to Tell" doesn't win the Silver Jubilee album rate...

genetic fail · , 11:08 AM

How about something from the boys?

AKA Year of the Gentlemen (Ne-Yo) v. Confessions (Usher) v. Doo-Wops and Hooligans (Mars) v. Justified (Timberlake)

can you improve my suggestion?

TakeItOff! · , 2:51 AM

Can we get Kanye into an Album Rate? Maybe a critically acclaimed album rate - MBDTF vs... idk, Robyn? Maybe the sole good M.I.A. album whose name escapes me?

Get into it, Ace.

Venus · , 4:22 AM

2011 Debuts:

Heat 1:
Who You Are vs With The Music I Die vs Colours vs The Night The Sun Came Up vs Sticks & Stones

Heat 2:
Killer Love vs Saxobeats vs Cinderella's Eyes vs Alexis Jordan vs Perfectionist

Nait Phoenix · , 2:58 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by genetic fail

How about something from the boys?

AKA Year of the Gentlemen (Ne-Yo) v. Confessions (Usher) v. Doo-Wops and Hooligans (Mars) v. Justified (Timberlake)

can you improve my suggestion?

It could be a contemporary R&B male sophomore album rate.

Usher (My Way)
vs
Justin Timberlake (FutureSex/LoveSounds)
vs
Ne-Yo (Because of You)
vs
The-Dream (Love vs. Money)
vs
Chris Brown (Exclusive)

That would be an epic list to judge, if I do say myself.

sticks · , 3:28 PM

Ellie Goulding vs. Lungs vs. La Roux vs. 19 vs. The Family Jewels

British Female Tastemakers Debuts?

Nait Phoenix · , 3:36 PM

I have to wait for TakeItOff's album rate to do mine, right? Or can I just start it now?

Venus · , 3:38 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by sticks

Ellie Goulding vs. Lungs vs. La Roux vs. 19 vs. The Family Jewels

British Female Tastemakers Debuts?

1. Lights
2. Lungs
3. 19
4. The Family Jewels
5. La Roux

Anything else is wrong.

Ace Reject · , 3:50 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Nait Phoenix

I have to wait for TakeItOff's album rate to do mine, right? Or can I just start it now?

Wait until it's started - until he actually posts the results - and then do it. Yours is in similar territory to Keir's rate, and I don't want posters to get Brit-Mainstream Popped out.

genetic fail · , 10:10 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Nait Phoenix

It could be a contemporary R&B male sophomore album rate.

Usher (My Way)
vs
Justin Timberlake (FutureSex/LoveSounds)
vs
Ne-Yo (Because of You)
vs
The-Dream (Love vs. Money)
vs
Chris Brown (Exclusive)

That would be an epic list to judge, if I do say myself.

Future Sex/ Love Sounds will already be rated in another rate.

plus I really want Doo-Wops on the list...

Ace Reject · , 10:14 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by genetic fail

Future Sex/ Love Sounds will already be rated in another rate.

plus I really want Doo-Wops on the list...

I say go for it.

But, looking at the schedule, it probably won't be until February.