[Artisticguy99]

Originally posted by Ramcoro

4, Madonna will never have another successful era.

Oh really? that's what everyone said after erotica in 1992 and then again in 2003 after she released american life, madonna has proven her haters wrong many times, i don't even know why you bother

[Jabril]

Flop.

[Mariah4life]

flop. songs dont fit her

[Nikko]

4

[getback]

4) Total Flop

end topic

[OnlyManInTheWorld]

Massive flop.

[B2R4D]

Lesser success.

[CoolestPerson12]

When was the last time Madonna had a hit single (a real hit with longevity). This would've flopped.

[Ainsworth]

Originally posted by CoolestPerson12

When was the last time Madonna had a hit single (a real hit with longevity). This would've flopped.

2005.

[berberocka]

More successful than MDNA tbh!

[Chileno]

Flop

[TVilla]

It would've performed better because this is in a total different direction then her last albums.

[CoolestPerson12]

Originally posted by Ainsworth

2005.

And did she have other hits from the album?

[Lucas32]

Originally posted by RaeseanLohan

Lesser success.

This

[Kaluda]

If Madonna released BTW, it'd look so... reductive.

[Swag]

Flop, the songwriting is weak on BTW tbh

[iseeyouupsidedown]

wouldn't a "lesser success" still be a flop in this case? BTW sold because it was Gaga and Gaga was the biggest name in pop music at the time. Look at the single performance after BTW the song and you can tell had anyone else released such an album it would've 100% flopped.

[MohammadMonster]

4) Total Flop

[Robert]

It would be seen as reductive although no one would know that word.

[J-esper]

I don't think it would be good tbh, it would sell decent, but the songs are basically more about being young and being yourself and find out who you are etc. If Madonna would have released it the same time as Gaga originally did, it would not give the same message and also probably wouldn't target the people who Gaga reached with her lyrics.