[rihannabiggestfan]

Can't Be Tamed

[GabeEd]

Originally posted by pika

Now, sis. While I would agree on most occasions, going top ten & platinum >>> going platinum and Top 30.

And while I would agree on most occasions, going top 30, having better longevity and almost 2x platinum >>> going top 10, not having longevity and barely going platinum.

[mike_10]

why are everyone trying to bash selena, it's her birtdhay, give her a break btw, if u want to know the successful one, you just have look up for receipts in the internet

to answer the question, in the US KISS & Tell sold 864,135 copies with a platinum top 30 while CBT sold like 337k with a platinum top 10, i think it's not fair to compare tours since miley performed in arenas while selena jusst performed in small places in that era so idk about worlwide tho

[Middle of Selena]

Originally posted by pika

Now, sis. While I would agree on most occasions, going top ten & platinum >>> going platinum and Top 30.

really CBT got the platinum plaque?

[pika]

Originally posted by GabeEd

And while I would agree on most occasions, going top 30, having better longevity and almost 2x platinum >>> going top 10, not having longevity and barely going platinum.

Can't Be Tamed didn't have the best longevity, but it spent 10 weeks on the BB Hot 100, a little over 2 months. Besides, going top ten isn't easy, and especially for the fifth time is impressive on its own, regardless of longevity.

Plus, singles aren't the only thing that go into what era is 'more successful'. Tour, impact, and album sales count too.

[Keira]

Can't Be Tamed

[Trent]

Kiss & Tell sold 864,135 in America & over a million worldwide and had a Platinum single.
Can't Be Tamed sold 337,000 in America & like 700k worldwide.
Enough said.

[SixWholeYears]

CBT>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> the other attempt

[SixWholeYears]

Originally posted by Trent

Kiss & Tell went Gold in America. Over a million worldwide.
Everyone (in America) knows Naturally.
Nobody (in America) knows Can't Be Tamed or Who Owns My Heart.

How can you speak for "everyone" or "nobody"?

[GabeEd]

Originally posted by pika

Can't Be Tamed didn't have the best longevity, but it spent 10 weeks on the BB Hot 100, a little over 2 months. Besides, going top ten isn't easy, and especially for the fifth time is impressive on its own, regardless of longevity.

Plus, singles aren't the only thing that go into what era is 'more successful'. Tour, impact, and album sales count too.

I never said Kiss & Tell was more succesful all around. Obviously, Kiss & Tell did much better in the US. In both single and album sales. Selena did small venues to get her name out there and Miley didn't even tour the US. So touring in the US shouldn't even be included. Therefor, without a doubt, Selena did better in the US.

Worldwide tho, Can't Be Tamed did better.

But comparing a debut album by a Disney star with a 3rd (4th if you count TTOOL) album by an ex-Disney star is a bit unfair. If it were WTSGD and CBT that would've been a whole different story.

[HotDamnMiley]

Originally posted by Trent

Kiss & Tell went Gold in America. Over a million worldwide.
Everyone (in America) knows Naturally.
Nobody (in America) knows Can't Be Tamed or Who Owns My Heart.

1. I'm pretty sure Naturally is not that well known.
2. Many people DO know of Can't Be Tamed.
3. Who Owns My Heart Wasn't even released in the US.
4. LASTLY, what about Falling Down??

[minxie]

✺ Kiss & Tell went #1 in zero countries and went top 10 in six. It sold 68,000 copies worldwide in its first week. It's sold 1.1 million copies to date, being Selena's best selling album.
✺ Can't Be Tamed went #1 in two countries and went top 10 in twenty-one. It sold 232,000 copies worldwide in its first week. It's sold 1.5 million copies to date, being Miley's lowest selling album.

✺ Kiss & Tell is certified platinum in zero countries.
✺ Can't Be Tamed is certified platinum in two countries.
✺ Kiss & Tell is certified gold in three countries.
✺ Can't Be Tamed is certified gold in four countries.

✺ Falling Down charted in four countries and peaked within the top 10 of zero, with purported sales of 400k.
✺ Can't Be Tamed charted in 19 countries and peaked within the top 10 of 5, with sales upwards of 1,000,000.

✺ Selena sold out theaters, state fairs and rodeos & livestock shows on her tour which grossed likely around $500,000 from 19 shows.
✺ Miley sold out arenas and stadiums on her tour which was one of the highest grossing mid-year worldwide, with $26 million from 21 shows.

✺ Miley made $48 million in 2010, and $15 million in 2011 according to Forbes.
✺ Selena has never made Forbes.



So there's that.

[pika]

Originally posted by GabeEd

I never said Kiss & Tell was more succesful all around. Obviously, Kiss & Tell did much better in the US. In both single and album sales. Selena did small venues to get her name out there and Miley didn't even tour the US. So touring in the US shouldn't even be included. Therefor, without a doubt, Selena did better in the US.

Worldwide tho, Can't Be Tamed did better.

But comparing a debut album by a Disney star with a 3rd (4th if you count TTOOL) album by an ex-Disney star is a bit unfair. If it were WTSGD and CBT that would've been a whole different story.

Let's not get too messy, Gabe. But I agree with what you said.

[Gossip_Boy]

Originally posted by Trent

Kiss & Tell went Gold in America. Over a million worldwide.
Everyone (in America) knows Naturally.
Nobody (in America) knows Can't Be Tamed or Who Owns My Heart.

Because 'Who Owns My Heart' wasn't a US single.

And again Miley with a flop era sold more WW than Selena so what's the point of this? WW > US

WW sales: Miley
Tour: Miley
Impact: Miley

[jomarr]

Can't Be Tamed was more successful but Naturally ***** on everything Miley has released

#truthtea

[Trent]

Originally posted by Gossip_Boy

Because 'Who Owns My Heart' wasn't a US single.

And again Miley with a flop era sold more WW than Selena so what's the point of this? WW > US

WW sales: Miley
Tour: Miley
Impact: Miley

Actually, she didn't sell better WW. Miley stans just love that OceanUP article.

[pika]

Originally posted by Trent

Kiss & Tell went Gold in America. Over a million worldwide.
Everyone (in America) knows Naturally.
Nobody (in America) knows Can't Be Tamed or Who Owns My Heart.

WaiT, considering that WOMH wasn't even released in the US, I wouldn't expect anybody to know of it.

[Gossip_Boy]

Originally posted by kaleidoscope

✺ Kiss & Tell went #1 in zero countries and went top 10 in six. It sold 68,000 copies worldwide in its first week. It's sold 1.1 million copies to date, being Selena's best selling album.
✺ Can't Be Tamed went #1 in two countries and went top 10 in twenty-one. It sold 232,000 copies worldwide in its first week. It's sold 1.5 million copies to date, being Miley's lowest selling album.

✺ Kiss & Tell is certified platinum in zero countries.
✺ Can't Be Tamed is certified platinum in two countries.
✺ Kiss & Tell is certified gold in three countries.
✺ Can't Be Tamed is certified gold in four countries.

✺ Falling Down charted in four countries and peaked within the top 10 of zero, with purported sales of 400k.
✺ Can't Be Tamed charted in 19 countries and peaked within the top 10 of 5, with sales upwards of 1,000,000.

✺ Selena sold out theaters, state fairs and rodeos & livestock shows on her tour which grossed likely around $500,000 from 19 shows.
✺ Miley sold out arenas and stadiums on her tour which was one of the highest grossing mid-year worldwide, with $26 million from 21 shows.

✺ Miley made $48 million in 2010, and $15 million in 2011 according to Forbes.
✺ Selena has never made Forbes.



So there's that.

And the true tea has been spilled.

[Retro]

Kiss & Tell.

In addition, "Naturally" beats all but one song in Miley's discography, and that's not even Selena's best song.

[Middle of Selena]

Originally posted by kaleidoscope

✺ Kiss & Tell went #1 in zero countries and went top 10 in six. It sold 68,000 copies worldwide in its first week. It's sold 1.1 million copies to date, being Selena's best selling album.
✺ Can't Be Tamed went #1 in two countries and went top 10 in twenty-one. It sold 232,000 copies worldwide in its first week. It's sold 1.5 million copies to date, being Miley's lowest selling album.

✺ Kiss & Tell is certified platinum in zero countries.
✺ Can't Be Tamed is certified platinum in two countries.
✺ Kiss & Tell is certified gold in three countries.
✺ Can't Be Tamed is certified gold in four countries.

✺ Falling Down charted in four countries and peaked within the top 10 of zero, with purported sales of 400k.
✺ Can't Be Tamed charted in 19 countries and peaked within the top 10 of 5, with sales upwards of 1,000,000.

✺ Selena sold out theaters, state fairs and rodeos & livestock shows on her tour which grossed likely around $500,000 from 19 shows.
✺ Miley sold out arenas and stadiums on her tour which was one of the highest grossing mid-year worldwide, with $26 million from 21 shows.

✺ Miley made $48 million in 2010, and $15 million in 2011 according to Forbes.
✺ Selena has never made Forbes.



So there's that.

what nonsense
dumbass again talking about peaks lets compare their us sales lets compare Naturally and CBT funny that Selena singles from her debut album sold more than your fave uhmm 6..7.. single?
i told u before HM is over and your fav