[Soda Pop Queen]

She really shines when she's at her piano but I don't find her to be a natural performer when she's away from it.

I wonder how she would do and look if she stripped away the theatricality in her shows, the props, and eccentric costumes

[BoyOnBoy Wonder]

Yes- seeing that Gaga has more involvement in the writing and production aspects than Bey.

Bey's a close second though.

[givemethatpop]

Originally posted by CoolestPerson12

Actually Beyoncè is.

But Beyoncé doesn't write ****.

That's the huge, vast difference between her and Lady Gaga.

[B94]

Originally posted by BPD

No, Beyonce is.

1+

[Artemisia]

Definitely.

But then she has a little problem because of this.

Gaga doesn't excel in any area.

[givemethatpop]

Originally posted by Soda Pop Queen

She really shines when she's at her piano but I don't find her to be a natural performer when she's away from it.

I wonder how she would do and look if she stripped away the theatricality in her shows, the props, and eccentric costumes

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x-gkBiy3djk

[BoyOnBoy Wonder]

Originally posted by Underdogs

P!nk is better than Gaga at everything. Except fashion (if that matters to anyone)

But seriously. She's definitely not. She lacks the most important aspect of a well-rounded popstar: cultural impact. She hasn't impacted a single thing in pop culture or even music.

Originally posted by RatedG²

2nd is X

Isn't success an important factor in the well-roundedness of a popstar?

[givemethatpop]

Originally posted by BoyOnBoy Wonder

Isn't success an important factor in the well-roundedness of a popstar?

It could be but it wasn't considered in this thread. Otherwise, there would be no P!nk discussion.

[ClashAndBurn]

Originally posted by Artemisia

Definitely.

But then she has a little problem because of this.

Gaga doesn't excel in any area.

That's the biggest issue with her, really... Jack of all trades, master of none.

[jayyyxtee]

Originally posted by Underdogs

She only worked with Luke on three songs. None of them went number 1, unfortunately.

P!nk is the 'mother' of Pop-Rock in this century and there are a lot of people co-opting her sound. Whatever pop-rock we see today, p!nk did it on M!ssundaztood (with the help of Linda Perry, of course.)

And mainly, her originality is reflected in her performances. What main stream artist has done acrobatics(silk, trapeze, bungee etc) while singing before P!nk?

Sis I love me some P!nk so don't make me argue with you

[Reza]

Originally posted by jeremyyy

Cause beauty is the only thing your fave has to sell records.

People don't watch music sweetie, they listen to it.

[Scuba_Dive]

Easily.

[gettsleazy]

Beyoncé is more well rounded and a better person in general than Gaga, just because she doesn't seem to throw her morals around, and is a humble person, unlike Gaga ("My album is the album of the decade")

[Evangeline]

Originally posted by Artemisia

Definitely.

But then she has a little problem because of this.

Gaga doesn't excel in any area.

But that isn't really a 'problem' since she's considerable good at so many things.All of that combined definitely takes her overall level of talent and potential to a high level.And she does excel at various things if you consider the current standards in the pop music scene.
Anyways,ofcourse being all-rounded doesn't necessarily mean being superior to everyone,and that's not what this thread is trying to prove.The level of skill and specialisation in a field definitely matters.Question is just : Is she the most all-rounded?

[DejaVu]

NO.

Beyonce

[Evangeline]

Originally posted by gettsleazy

Beyoncé is a better person in general than Gaga, just because she doesn't seem to throw her morals around, and is a humble person, unlike Gaga ("My album is the album of the decade")

You really think that's a good argument?Some ppl in this thread = definition of pressed.

[DejaVu]

Originally posted by givemethatpop

But Beyoncé doesn't write ****.

That's the huge, vast difference between her and Lady Gaga.

And Gaga can't dance or sing well, but try she does.

[Sye]

Originally posted by gettsleazy

Beyoncé is more well rounded and a better person in general than Gaga, just because she doesn't seem to throw her morals around, and is a humble person, unlike Gaga ("My album is the album of the decade")

lol

[Haus]

She is the complete package. She can write, direct, and produce, she puts 110% into her tours, she loves her fans more than anyone, she knows how to dress right, and she's one of the controversial stars of this century.

[givemethatpop]

Originally posted by gettsleazy

Beyoncé is more well rounded and a better person in general than Gaga, just because she doesn't seem to throw her morals around, and is a humble person, unlike Gaga ("My album is the album of the decade")

''I represent this generation's talent'' much?