[Sunshine.]

Beyoncé could pull them all off. She's so versatile.

[aaronsmithjune1]

Beyonce could easily do TTT & 21

[Javan]

Originally posted by aaronsmithjune1

If lady GaGa recorded 4 Lady Gaga simply does not have the singing abilty

If Beyonce recorded talk that talk Everyone would love another Bey and Jay collab so it would probs smash

If Rihanna recorded born this way I'm trying to imagine Rihanna singing Judas. Even she can't get away with that after Umbrella. That would be her career done

If Britney recorded 21 Does she posses the ability tho?

If Adele recorded femme fatale I wouldn't mind. But I wouldn't buy it either way.

What would be the outcome commercially & critically? If these artist recorded these albums.

.

[Reza]

Originally posted by RatedG²

DEATH @ the thought of Adele performing Big Fat Bass

I could possibly see Rihanna doing BTW (the song) but that's about it. Nothing else would work

Gaga couldn't do anything on 4 AT ALL...not even Run The World

The rest seem plausible...I can see Bey doing half of TTT

It's getting biggah the bass is getting biggah!

[Ozzy8923]

I think Rihanna could pull off BTW very well, especially Government Hooker, Electric Chapel, Marry the Night, and Judas. The Edge of Glory is the only song that Rihanna is not really suited to sing.

Gaga can easily sing all of the songs on 4 minus Countdown. No one can do that "Booooyyyyyyyy"!

Britney and 21 would be a mess beyond human understanding. The only song I can see Britney pulling of is MAYBE Rumour Has It.

Beyonce can pull of most of the songs on TTT. Especially Farewell and Watch N' Learn. The only songs that I think Rihanna sings better is Where Have You Been and We Found Love. I can REALLY see Beyonce slaying Talk that Talk (the song, after all her husband is on it) and You Da One.

Dear God, if Adele recorded Femme Fatale it would be a mess of epic proportions.

I think BTW would be less commercially successful with Rihanna doing it, the same with Britney doing 21 and Adele doing Femme Fatale. If Beyonce did TTT, I can see it being MUCH more successful and the same goes with Gaga recording 4.

[Cosmos]

Okay, let me actually give a substantive reply...

Beyoncé could probably do alright with Talk That Talk.
I think Rihanna and maybe Gaga could have done some of Femme Fatale.
No one else could have done Born This Way or 4.
And 21, well...I think Beyoncé could have pulled it off, assuming some horrible alternate universe where she and Jay-Z went through a bitter divorce.

Now, what about if we add Katy, Kesha, Teenage Dream and Animal/Cannibal to the mix?

[B94]

If Rihanna recorded born this way

If Britney recorded 21

If Adele recorded femme fatale

If lady GaGa recorded 4

All of them would sound hit trying to sing most of those songs. Even though I think Adele would slay HATLM. And the thought of Britney trying to sing songs off 21 is hilarious, she would butcher anything that required belting or any high notes period. Gaga would have to shout trying to sing sing I Care or anything vocally challenging. Beyonce would be able to pull off TTT, that's easy.

[Lucas32]

Now I kinda want Drunk on love from Bey

[Walley]

If lady GaGa recorded 4 - Impossible

If Beyonce recorded talk that talk - It would work and be more successful than 4, but she would never do that to her fans.

If Rihanna recorded born this way - It would need a few tweaks to sound more urban, but it would work overall.

If Britney recorded 21 - There would be a worldwide plague of bloody ears

If Adele recorded femme fatale - The album would actually feature good vocals

[Damien M]

Originally posted by gettsleazy

I could honestly see Britney singing Rolling in the Deep....

Wait.... what?

Anyway, Beyonce could pull off Talk That Talk, but not very convincingly. The rest though.

[RatedG²]

Originally posted by Reza

It's getting biggah the bass is getting biggah!

Don't do it

[Ozzy8923]

I just though of Taylor Swift recording Talk that Talk. Imagine her singing "I want that CAKE CAKE CAKE CAKE."

[UnusualBoy]

The mess would be Adele doing FF or Britney doing 21

[aaronsmithjune1]

Rihanna could do born this way excellent IMO

[B94]

Originally posted by gettsleazy

I could honestly see Britney singing Rolling in the Deep but aside of that....

No way. Imagine Britney singing Florence's No light No light?

[Johnny]

I'm only here for Beyonce and Talk That Talk, she's the only one I think would pull it off.

[Wet]

Lady Gaga singing 1+1 or I Care ....

[aaronsmithjune1]

Originally posted by Reza

It's getting biggah the bass is getting biggah!

keep it clean girl

[kgeezy310]

Originally posted by gettsleazy

I could see Bey TRYING TTT but it would probably be a mess.

Lady Gaga doesn't have the voice and personality to even be able to touch the masterpiece that was "4"

Adele singing FF... would be interesting?

I could honestly see Britney singing Rolling in the Deep but aside of that....

WHAT......how dare you blaspheme that masterpiece in such a way.....

[humbz]

Rihanna singing Electric Chapel would be SO Rated R-ish.