[Addicted]

You & I.

[Luigi]

You and I.
I never liked Wide Awake, but I love You and I.

[Nikko]

You&I for both, of course.

[lilMonsterKayla]

Y&I for both, WA is a mediocre song and the video looks like an advertisement for RuneScape.

[Calypso]

You and I

[evan93]

You and I

[Sonny]

Originally posted by lilMonsterKayla

Y&I for both, WA is a mediocre song and the video looks like an advertisement for RuneScape.

[Squall]

WA even if I love You and I.

I vote both for the videos because You and I is my favorite video from BTW era (if I really have to choose I'd go with WA but I vote both).

[ALA]

You + I for both.

[rihannabiggestfan]

Wide Awake for both

[Jabril]

Song: You and I
Video: You and I

[GaGaFan]

You and I for both honestly but it is pretty close.

[Santaus]

This isn't even a fair comparison. Y&I is such a bore, and its video is an utter mess. Obviously WA for both.

[Archetype]

You and I is a classic. I mean, it's a Brian May (of Queen) collaboration. No contest here.
I like Wide Awake, but the video is beyond tacky and cliche. You and I is difficult to follow, but there's something about it that is very intriguing.

[Porygon2z]

Yoü and I, both, in my opinion.