[mermaid_ariel]

RN.

is better then all of them tbh.

[Mr. Fahrenheit]

Like a Prayer. It's ****ing Art.



I like Rhythm Nation a lot - probably my favourite Janet album, so that's 2nd.

Then... I don't know. I've never liked Mariah Carey's stuff, and 4 is messy.

[Callum]

rhythm nation

[SLAYANNA NAVY]

Rhythm Nation>>>4>>Daydream>>Like A Prayer

[Duca]

Like a Prayer, by a landslide.

[King B]

4...It shall become a classic in the future.

[Kisuke]

4 is the best ones.

followed by janet hers.

[UnusualBoy]

Out of those I'd say:

LAV > RN > DD > 4

4 can't be considered a classic when it only was out last year

[BnPac]

Originally posted by Damien M

4 does not belong on this list (...yet).

Why? Because it is not old enough? Snce when do we judge quality on how long the album has been out or how big the impact was? So biased. The question in the OP was : "which one is better?"

I'll probably say LAP.

[Damien M]

Originally posted by BnPac

Why? Because it is not old enough? Snce when do we judge quality on how long the album has been out or how big the impact was? So biased. The question in the OP was : "which one is better?"

I'll probably say LAP.

Uhhhh.....no. I'm not even talking about the impact.


Yes, the timeframe counts.The other 3 albums have been out for more than 15 years
. 4 was released just last year. We don't know well how it will hold up musically in 3 years, let alone 15 years from now.

[QueenJ]

Like A Prayer

[Wii]

Daydream > Rhythm Nation 1814 > 4

I haven't listen to Madonna album and i don't have the desire to tbh

[superben]

Like a Prayer > Rhythm Nation >>>>>> the other 2

[Smooth Criminal]

The one with 7 top 5 singles.

I have to stan, tho. All of them are perfect.

[Kool_Aid_King]

Voted for 4 even though I know it's not the best. Just my favorite.

Basically, here is the CORRECT answer.

Rhythm Nation > Daydream (Fantasy was her most important song in her entire career) = Like a Prayer > 4

Also, where is Rated R? That was Rihanna's most critically applauded work and was also her 4th album

[Praise Mariallah]

Originally posted by Kool_Aid_King

Voted for 4 even though I know it's not the best. Just my favorite.

Basically, here is the CORRECT answer.

Rhythm Nation > Daydream (Fantasy was her most important song in her entire career) = Like a Prayer > 4

Also, where is Rated R? That was Rihanna's most critically applauded work and was also her 4th album

Pretty much.

And I don't know if "Fantasy" was Mariah's most important song, but it's better than everything (by miles) on LaP save the title track and better than anything on 4. Underneath The Stars and Always Be My Baby are pluses as well.

[alkralkra]

1. Rhythm Nation
2. 4
3. LAP
4. Daydream

Fantasy isn't even that great.

[Kool_Aid_King]

Originally posted by Praise Mariallah

Pretty much.

And I don't know if "Fantasy" was Mariah's most important song, but it's better than everything (by miles) on LaP save the title track and better than anything on 4. Underneath The Stars and Always Be My Baby are pluses as well.

No, it definitely was. Mariah said it herself that it was her most important song. Mostly because it was one of the first songs to perfectly merge Pop & Hip Hop together and put it into the mainstream. It paved the way for songs like Crazy in Love & Umbrella.

[Rihannito]

Rhythm Nation by miles.