[Bahjat]

Oh by the way people , if Kelly thought Taylor was immature in writing lyrics , she wouldn't cover her songs on tour .

[supertiffany]

Singing Kelly is 10 Taylor is 1 especially live


Songwriting let's compare the hitsongs? Because of You,Behind These Hazel Eyes, Sober are far better written and composed than Taylor's Love Story, You Belong With Me


I mean all I can hear is princess, fairy tales, blue jeans and whatever immature teenage girls words crusing over a handsome guy.

Her writing seems to be very flat, and not growing.


Actually Taylor Swift is overrated, there are more artists talented than her especially vocally

good thing she's a country singer with poppy songs. big crossover, big geographical and racial back-up. also not much competition in the country world to add

[Bahjat]

Originally posted by MissBreakaway

Well, Kelly was a teenager when she wrote Because of You...you can't even hear that BOY was written by a teenager cause it's so deep. She had deeper stuff to write about than high school

It's not like all of Taylor's songs consist of Prince and Princess . go check her debut . there are songs that were written by her when she was 13 / 14 .

[MissBreakaway]

Never said that Kelly thinks Taylor is immature. Kelly likes everyone, even Justin Bieber. BTW, wasn't it Taylor who named a song Back To December? My December, anyone?

[givemethatpop]

TAYLOR

[[Bask]]

Originally posted by Bahjat

Oh by the way people , if Kelly thought Taylor was immature in writing lyrics , she wouldn't cover her songs on tour .

Just for fun

[supertiffany]

Originally posted by givemethatpop

I didn't know Kelly had any talent apart from a decent voice

TAYLOR.

so what was Taylor's talent that she is superior to Kelly. instruments? because songwriting Kelly still beats her. so what then?


Also why you need to have multiple talents, so as just to cover up your horrible singing skills?

[castle13]

Originally posted by supertiffany

Singing Kelly is 10 Taylor is 1 especially live


Songwriting let's compare the hitsongs? Because of You,Behind These Hazel Eyes, Sober are far better written and composed than Taylor's Love Story, You Belong With Me


I mean all I can hear is princess, fairy tales, blue jeans and whatever immature teenage girls words crusing over a handsome guy.

Her writing seems to be very flat, and not growing.


Actually Taylor Swift is overrated, there are more artists talented than her especially vocally

good thing she's a country singer with poppy songs. big crossover, big geographical and racial back-up. also not much competition in the country world to add

Of coure you'll compare the hits only. Yes ignore the other tracks because they are irrelevant. Great. And even YBWM>>>>> It wouldn't be nominated for SOTY for nothing

[Bahjat]

Originally posted by MissBreakaway

Never said that Kelly thinks Taylor is immature. Kelly likes everyone, even Justin Bieber. BTW, wasn't it Taylor who named a song Back To December? My December, anyone?

Yes , it was . it's not like Kelly owns '' December '' .



Stronger by Kanye West , anyone?

[MissBreakaway]

Originally posted by castle13

Of coure you'll compare the hits only. Yes ignore the other tracks because they are irrelevant. Great. And even YBWM>>>>> It wouldn't be nominated for SOTY for nothing

Check the list of people who have never won a grammy. (Led Zeppelin, the Doors, Jimi Hendrix). Then you'll know winning a grammy doesn't even say a **** about the actual quality of your music. It just means the industry licks your butt and you have good sales in the mainstream department.

[supertiffany]

Originally posted by castle13

Of coure you'll compare the hits only. Yes ignore the other tracks because they are irrelevant. Great. And even YBWM>>>>> It wouldn't be nominated for SOTY for nothing

DID you know that Kelly's other tracks were also better written than her hits that makes it >>>>> Taylor's other tracks. same old rhythms especially her singles her first was the only listenable was TDIMG and it was fresh listening to it but it got repetitive with WH and other songs that has the same theme and sound

[castle13]

Originally posted by MissBreakaway

Check the list of people who have never won a grammy. (Led Zeppelin, the Doors, Jimi Hendrix). Then you'll know winning a grammy doesn't even say a **** about the actual quality of your music. It just means the industry licks your butt and you have good sales in the mainstream department.

So you're using the grammy ain't relevant card? So the 2 grammys she won are nothing? Okay.

[castle13]

Originally posted by Bahjat

Yes , it was . it's not like Kelly owns '' December '' .



Stronger by Kanye West , anyone?

IKR?

[Addicted]

Originally posted by castle13

Of coure you'll compare the hits only. Yes ignore the other tracks because they are irrelevant. Great. And even YBWM>>>>> It wouldn't be nominated for SOTY for nothing

That's because Kelly actually has hits, Taylors last top 10 was in 2010.

[Bahjat]

Originally posted by MissBreakaway

Check the list of people who have never won a grammy. (Led Zeppelin, the Doors, Jimi Hendrix). Then you'll know winning a grammy doesn't even say a **** about the actual quality of your music. It just means the industry licks your butt and you have good sales in the mainstream department.

Check the list of people who have won multiple Grammys

George Solti
Quincy Jones
Pierre Boulez
Vladimir Horowitz
Stevie Wonder
Henry Mancini
U2
The Beatles
Paul Simon
Billy Joel
George Michael
Bob Dylan
Norah Jones
Adele

.... etc

Guess they're all talentless people , you're right !

[Bahjat]

Originally posted by Addicted

That's because Kelly actually has hits, Taylors last top 10 was in 2010.

Kelly's last million seller in the US was in 2004 .

[muddysquirrel]

Originally posted by MissBreakaway;10313197[B

]It might be a question of taste who is the better songwriter, [/B]but Kelly is unarguably the better singer.

No its not.

Lets face it most of the votes against Taylor come from pressed souls who`s wig Taylor has snatched in the past or from people who are not very familiar with her work and fall into stereotypes like "she only writes about fairytales".

I`d say its a tie actually between the 2 ladies. They are both very talented....more talented than most of the other gurls atrl stans for.

[Addicted]

Originally posted by Bahjat

Kelly's last million seller in the US was in 2004 .

When was Love Story released, 2009 or something, well that was the last time Taylor was heard of outside the U.S

And Stronger is going to hit platinum.

[supertiffany]

Originally posted by Bahjat

Kelly's last million seller in the US was in 2004 .

you know a platinum in pop is triple platinum in country right