I say 2011 because she stood on her own, not with Elton performance wise. And that performance was amazing, her singing and dancing were on point, probably the best of BTW era. And her televised win that night was everything.
I loved 2010. Her outfits were amazing and the performance with Elton was such an incredible moment.
BUT, I think I prefer 2011 because the whole concept of her performance, from the red carpet to the stage was such an iconic moment in her career and Grammy history. The performance was amazing (the first ever live performance of Born This Way) and her vocals were amazing with all of the dancing. Plus, it was one of the launching points of the Born This Way era.
Which night was more iconic? 2011 and 2010 were both iconic in a sense
Which night's success was greater? 2011, she slayed everyone that night, it was HER NIGHT!!!!!!!!!
Which night did she look the best? 2010, that ****ing egg this is creepy and tacky as ****
Which night's performance was better? both were so damn good, i cant choose.