Madonna's Confessions On Dancefloor is n22 on the top 50 album list of Rolling Stone, making it the highest pop album on the list! Mariah's The Emancipation Of Mimi is only n43!

http://www.rollingstone.com/special/8952414?rnd=1134905946234&has-player=true&version=6.0.12.1059

Bye Mimi!

Kanye is n1 :-\

You're the one whos always complaining about the Madonna/Mariah rivalry, why start a new thread about it? Are you really that stupid?

You're the one whos always complaining about the Madonna/Mariah rivalry, why start a new thread about it? Are you really that stupid?

About 30 Mimi fans registered at a Madonna forum and caused a commonation. I'm really mad now! ****** Mimi!

So you're taking it out on Mariah here on ATRL? That doesn't really make sense ;)

Take it out on those fans on the Madonna forum for being so lame and pathetic, rather then bringing it here.

Plus I think you may have forgotten that Mariah has a lot of RnB on that album.

yeah it dosent make sense. i like both of them so i dont really care

eh. That chart is sorta BS anyways.

Ban this freak immediately.

woah, kinda harsh there Mazen, <3 your avatar and siggy though, cuz it makes me laugh!

Like this means QUALITY. :rofl:

TEOM isn't even pop. Its basicly all R&B.

But i dont give a **** about Mariah and Madonna!!

Cuz Fiona beat them both!!!!!!!
And Keyshia is on there!!

**** Rolling Stones...their charts and reviews always suck!

but of course... we all know that Mariah's cd is way better :D...

This sort of fan-created feud is so stupid and pointless. Either way, good for Madonna!

Yeah and Mimi is a lot better. So what's your point? RS is biased and can't help putting **** albums in the top of their countdown.

The fact that The Massacre is number 10 totally devalues that chart.

^that albun was the worst of the year :barf:

50 cent sucks :sick:

id take madonna over mariah because shes like a world icon and stuff, and mariah just pisses me off

but lets agree..

Madonna is a huge accomplished icon, and Mariah has had a succesful comeback
lets just be nice:)

madonna gave to mariah ONE huge kick, And it's necessary to mention that COADF went out to the selling at the end of this year and Mariah's TEOM has already like a year. madonna always better than mimi. COADF alwas better than TEOM. madonna the most selling of the world. and already predicted that her COADF will sell more than TEOM :banana11:

of the discussion and Kworb close this thread right now.

madonna gave to mariah ONE huge kick, And it's necessary to mention that COADF went out to the selling at the end of this year and Mariah's TEOM has already like a year. madonna always better than mimi. COADF alwas better than TEOM. madonna the most selling of the world. and already predicted that her COADF will sell more than TEOM :banana11:

of the discussion and Kworb close this thread right now.


umm speak english k thanks..... I'll take mariah over that old hag any day.

:clap: :clap: :clap:

www.mediatraffic.de (http://www.mediatraffic.de) - Madonna 5 weeks n1, Mariah onlly n16. This is the world. Mimi fans always use the USA to defend Mimi, but when it comes to the world they always hide.

No offense but who gives a **** about that top!! people rating music because they think they know a lot.

www.mediatraffic.de (http://www.mediatraffic.de/) - Madonna 5 weeks n1, Mariah onlly n16. This is the world. Mimi fans always use the USA to defend Mimi, but when it comes to the world they always hide.

WHATTT??? So for you the better option is the most popular?? This is not about defending her is about giving opinions.

By the way, who's that girl in your avatar? is it Lisa Marie Presley?

No offense but who gives a **** about that top!! people rating music because they think they know a lot.



WHATTT??? So for you the better option is the most popular?? This is not about defending her is about giving opinions.

By the way, who's that girl in your avatar? is it Lisa Marie Presley?

Mediatraffic is a fact, not an opinion. And that girl is my avatar is Mariah Carey.

Mediatraffic is a fact, not an opinion. And that girl is my avatar is Mariah Carey.


isn't pam Anderson in your avatar?

The Emancipation of Mimi > Confessions

I was kind of annoyed with Madonna's latest alblum, with the exception of 3 tracks I heard and liked.

RS talks about quality.
Billboard charts is just about quantity.

done.

This will change the fact that mariahs year has been Amaizing??

ask yourself that HATER!

The Constipation Of Caca (amazon reviews)

Stop eating and re-releasing your albums... We know that you're already a billionaire! But don't need to waste it all on food! girl, stop eating a little maybe you'll get pretty and then you'll start to sing some happy songs, no more crap like "don't forget about us" cuz he'll never leave you if you were thin!! Girl!

by the way, are you really that hungry?? How much more food can you need that you have to re-release your crap album 4 times to win a little more money?? And what's up with the rumors of having a 5th edition? Girl you're only diging yourself a bigger hole! But then again, you're gigantic, and I don't mean in sucessful, I mean really really fat! so you do need a BIG hole! just a notice, great comebacks don't happen to often so don't push your luck girl...

If the album were truly good, it wouldn't need 4 editions of it, it would have gone to sell just as much with only one! Besides, the only reason that it made it to 5x platinum is because die-hard stupid fans bought every single version! and it will continue to buy, until fat Carey reaches diamond status, even if it takes 20 re-releases... I wouldn't be surprised, she's really desperate for some food!

Man oh man Mariah, how can you call this music!? This has to be the worst record of the year. Even worse then Ashlee Simpsons! And please Mariah, enough with these ghetto braindead thugs that you have on some tracks. They should be surving me fast food at a drive thru. Not appearing on songs with you. Your better than that.

These songs are average, but I gave it one star because she's such a cash-in. You can't tell me she's not. You can't tell me that when she travelled 11 places from #15 to #4 this week on the Billboard and when she went 13 places from #47 to #34 in the UK because of the Platinum edition, that she wouldn't have laughed and not said: "Haha, you fools. I honestly only released this fourth edition of the album for your money." Pathetic.

Mariah Carey is the musical equivalent of a muppet. She can't carry a tune with a handle on it. Her songs are all produced by hot "current" trendy producers with rappers added in. She screams, howles, and does everything else but sing. The Grammy's made a horrible decision to nominate this fat, no talent cow. They probably want forgiveness for forgetting her for so long (butterfly album and daydream deserved grammys). Not This Constipation Of Miming !!!

i'm missing the old mariah. the realone.
I feel betrayed. But that's the point, Mariah had to make an alliance with hip hop, r&b... for reviving her faded musical career... But no matter how well this CD sells, her glory moments of her first CD won't come back again. The Emancipation of Mimi is garbage, pure trash. People are blind, Mariah is not innovative. Too many "featuring" songs... Where's her personal touch, her seal? Almost all her songs sound the same. How can people recognize her as the best selling and most successful female artist of all times? That's a big mistake. Please, count the copies again, then talk. And Mariah, retire please, and take some acting classes. You're such a bad actress, and video-clips need to be believable, for they are short films.

This is garbage....what is wrong with the world today. I have never heard a worse CD in my life. Mariah needs to retire or make ****, not music. Any person with good taste in music would rather lop off thier fingers one by one, then listen to this trash. This is the equivalent of Mariah Carey taking a poop and recording it to cd.

Mariah HAS NOT had more #1s than Madonna! OK, I understand. Mariah has had 16 #1s in the US - Madonna has had 12, yadda, yadda, yadda...

Mariah has had two UK #1s and Madonna has had 11. That's just two countries. See, it's proof Madonna is the Ultimate Pop Queen and that worldwide, people enjoy Madonna's music more.




her in real:

http://mapage.noos.fr/gotri/mi5.jpg
http://mapage.noos.fr/gotri/mi3.jpg

her on the cover in picture:

http://images.amazon.com/images/P/B000BO0LLS.01._SCLZZZZZZZ_.jpg

Wow, thank God Madge has other fans... Cause most of her fans from ATRL aren't something she can be proud of... :-X

lecritikeur is my favourite poster ever. :dies:

Wow, thank God Madge has other fans... Cause most of her fans from ATRL aren't something she can be proud of... :-X

Don't worry dear. Not all Madge fans are as annoying as I am. Most are to nice actually LOL. Madonna fans usually don't care about her chart positions, only if they like the music. Those are all true fans. Fans who love the artist just for her succes aren't. For example, these Mimi fans weren't fan of her in 2003 (Charmbracelet flop) and now they suddenley are. :rolleyes: I have also loved Madge duting the American life period, nomather it flopped, it remains my favourite Madonna album.

BTW, Mimi will deffo also have true fans, but those fans not visit ATRL. The ones that come her don0t post about how great Maroiah is, but about her chart positions. Well except one, forgot her/his name.

thanks bunny!
http://culturemp3.viabloga.com/images/fat15.jpg

It's so amusing how people reduce themselves to talking about an artist's appearance when they can't think of anything better.